clinical practice
Treated
poorly
or poorly
behaved?
Midwifery students say men are often
treated negatively in birthing suites, but
the bad behaviour goes both ways.
By Dallas Bastian
M
en are being ignored and dismissed in birthing suites –
but is their behaviour ever to blame?
An anonymous survey of midwifery students from
Edith Cowan University revealed they believe men are often
treated negatively in birthing suites.
Nine in 10 midwifery students on placement said they witnessed
male partners being ignored, treated condescendingly and
sometimes not given information before and during adverse
events or emergencies.
Researcher and midwife Christian Wright said doctors
and midwives were observed introducing themselves to and
addressing women only, not explaining common procedures to
men and asking them to leave during events.
One participant saw no problem with male partners being
ignored. "I don’t think doctors ignoring male partners is a
negative thing," the student said. "It isn’t about them – is it?”
Wright said: “Participants stated they observed male partners
being talked down to, receiving negative comments for yawning
or relaxing on the couch and being treated as annoyances."
But is some of this fair and reasonable behaviour on the part of
the midwife or doctor?
Participants called out men for adopting a "disinterested
bystander position". They said male partners were often
preoccupied with smartphones, the TV in the labour ward and
iPads during the birthing process.
One student said she saw men sleep through most of their
partner’s labour and bring in take-away food to eat in front of the
woman, knowing she couldn't eat.
Students also reported that men were "attention grabbing"
or engaging in "overbearing support", including trying to make
decisions on behalf of their partners.
20 | nursingreview.com.au
As one participant put it: “I’ve seen male partners try to influence
a woman against what the midwife is recommending. I’ve seen a
partner telling the midwife to get his partner an epidural, despite
the woman saying she didn’t want one. He wanted her to have one
because he couldn’t cope. He didn’t seem to be bothered about
what she wanted."
MILLENNIAL RIPPLES TURNING TIDES
Midwifery students held different views of male participation
than many experienced midwives, Wright said. Most referred
to what they do as family-centred care as opposed to
woman only‑centred care.
This term was offered unprompted, and Wright said it shows that
this new generation of midwives sees something in that idea.
He added midwives are seeking to be more inclusive of who the
family is, as determined by the woman.
“I know of hospitals that are looking at their guidelines so
that they’re not limiting the people in the room, so if someone’s
Male partners are not always included
at all phases of the process. They are
sometimes treated like a support person
instead of a father-to-be. Often there is an
assumption that men aren’t informed and
therefore can’t be part of the discussion...
support includes more than two people, then hopefully they can
facilitate that.”
Write said he hopes the research will motivate midwives to
continue to focus on the supports and partners of women as key.
“This study only focused on male partners but there are many
other partners a woman can have,” he said.
“Hopefully this has identified that we need to continue to
examine how we’re including partners.” ■