news
Robots can’t shortcircuit teen pregnancy
Electronic dolls designed to make child-rearing
unattractive to young girls are linked to higher
rates of high-school mums instead, in study.
I
t might be time to throw the electronic
baby out with the bath water.
Research shows educational dolls
designed to simulate the real experience
of having a baby don’t help cut teen
pregnancy rates. In fact, young girls
exposed to the robot babies are more likely
to get pregnant.
An Australian study published in The
Lancet has found that teenage girls who
used the dolls as part of a pregnancy
prevention program were more, not less,
likely to become pregnant.
The electronic Baby Think It Over dolls
were part of a Virtual Infant Parenting (VIP)
program run in 57 schools in Western
Australia, first implemented in 2003.
Similar programs, based on the
US concept, are now delivered in
89 countries, despite no robust
evidence of their effectiveness.
Researchers from the Telethon Kids
Healthy life,
happy head
Study finds an apple a day – and
working out, eating right and
avoiding liquor and cigarettes –
keeps the psychologist away.
P
eople with healthier lifestyles are less
likely to develop depression, a study
that followed 1200 people over five
years has found.
The research, published in the journal
Psychological Medicine, also found there
was a tendency for those with a history
6 | nursingreview.com.au
of depression to lose points in a lifestyle
assessment over the five years.
Researchers assessed lifestyles through
a rating comprising body mass index,
smoking, alcohol consumption, leisure
time, physical activity and diet. Study
lead Dr Seana Gall, from the University of
Institute in Western Australia conducted
a randomised controlled assessment of
the VIP program and warned that the
electronic babies were an ineffective use of
public funds.
Nearly 3000 Western Australia school
girls aged 13–15 participated in the study.
It was found the girls who were in the
VIP program had higher rates of pregnancy
by the age of 20, at 17 per cent, than those
who were not, at 11 per cent.
Of the girls who did fall pregnant, 58 per
cent had abortions, compared with 60 per
cent of girls from the control group.
While the researchers said this wasn’t
statistically significant, it did show girls
exposed to the program were more likely
to go through with the pregnancy.
Lead investigator Dr Sally Brinkman said
their study demonstrated that even the
most well-intentioned programs can have
“unexpected consequences”.
“Australia has the sixth-highest teen
pregnancy rate out of 21 OECD countries
and this study will help policymakers better
tackle the issue,” Brinkman said. ■
With AAP.
Tasmania’s Menzies Institute for Medical
Research, said the study’s grouping of
health behaviours was significant, as
studying individual risk factors and their
relationship with depression ignores
the fact that risk factors often cluster as
unhealthy lifestyles.
The team followed people aged 25–36 at
the start of the study. Gall said people with
healthier lifestyles at the outset were 22 per
cent less likely to develop a first episode of
depression over the five years, while people
with depression were 46 per cent more
likely to receive a lower score in a lifestyle
assessment over the same period.
“Our findings have implications for
reducing the higher risk of cardiovascular
disease that is seen in those with
depression and also potentially reducing
the risk of developing depression
in young people,” Gall said. “The
study highlights the need for holistic
management of young adults in terms
of their mental and physical health,
including health behaviours.”
The results suggest that a healthier
lifestyle may protect against the first
onset of depression, Gall said, adding this
means the findings are relevant for those
managing the physical and mental health
of younger adults. ■