workforce
‘We
must
not
lose
touch’
Technology is responsible for
many advances in medicine
but it cannot be allowed to
make us forget the value of
human physical contact.
Sue Dean interviewed by Dallas Bastian
M @suedeandean
N
urses have seen the value of touch and must keep it in
mind as healthcare technology advances.
This is one of the key messages Australian academics
made in a recent editorial in the Journal of Clinical Nursing.
They wrote that the increasing use of a variety of technological
supports for nursing work may be at the expense of offering a
comforting touch to patients.
While the authors say they are proponents of the use of
technology, they added that nurses must pay careful attention to
how they best integrate technology into practice without risking
the interpersonal relationship at the heart of their work.
“In embedding technology in nursing practice, it is imperative
that we consider how this [affects] nurse-patient relationships,” they
wrote. “We must not lose touch.”
Here, Nursing Review sits down with lead author Sue Dean, a
lecturer at the University of Technology Sydney, to discuss the
ways touch can affect the patient experience and how nurses can
ensure they aren’t losing sight of its importance.
NR: Where did the idea to explore this area, as in your editorial
“Is Technology Responsible for Nurses Losing Touch?”
come from?
SD: I’ve taught communication in nursing programs for more
than 20 years now and I was sitting around one morning with two
colleagues, one of them Dr Jo Lewis whose area of expertise is
palliative care, and another colleague, Dr Caleb Ferguson, whose
20 | nursingreview.com.au
area of clinical practice and research is in cardiac and stroke. Caleb
has also published quite a bit on social media and technology,
and the use of technology in nursing in a positive sense. We were
just talking about technology and about patient-centred care
and caring and compassion and how all of us were concerned
at the literature that’s around now about nurses not being as
compassionate and caring as we would like. We started thinking
about whether technology played a role in that; hence we got
together and wrote the editorial.
In your experience, why is nurse-patient physical contact so
important?
There is lots of evidence around that touch has an important,
therapeutic effect on patients. Even as early as when Florence
Nightingale started training nurses in the mid-1880s, she included
massage as a part of nurses’ qualifications. My co-authors and I, we
know [the importance of touch] from years and years of experience
just because we can see in patients how important it is when you just
sit and hold the hand of somebody. You don’t have to say any words,
you don’t have to do anything, just holding a hand has a therapeutic
effect. Giving someone a massage [can be comforting]. Often there
are no words to say to make a patient feel better or comforted and
touch is important. We’ve seen over decades of nursing practice just
how important that is.
What are some of the ways nurses may be offering comfort or
support through physical touch that they may not realise?
Going back to my experience, things like just holding a hand when a
patient has a painful experience. If someone is having an injection or
a dressing or something that’s quite painful, just holding their hand. [I
mean having] another nurse just saying to the patient: ‘Just squeeze
my hand as hard as you can if it’s hurting you.’ People are inventing
virtual reality things to put on patients when they’re undergoing
painful procedures, to distract them. There are many innovations now
in technology that are taking away the need to touch the patient.