industry & reform
Supporters of safe access zones gather outside NSW Parliament
House in June 2018. Photo: AAP/Peter Rae
‘Not a criminal issue’
Nursing association joins push to
decriminalise abortion in NSW.
By Kate Prendergast
A
peak nursing body has thrown
its support behind a campaign to
decriminalise abortion in NSW.
The New South Wales Nurses and
Midwives’ Association (NSWNMA) is one
of 70 signatories of the NSW Pro‑Choice
Alliance, a campaign launched by the
Women’s Electoral Lobby in early May.
Other signatories include family
planning centres, women’s health
centres, lawyers’ groups and domestic
violence prevention groups.
After a historic vote in Queensland
parliament late last year, NSW remains the
only Australian state yet to legalise abortion.
Under sections of the NSW Crimes Act,
enacted 119 years ago, women who access
abortion, and health practitioners who
help facilitate this choice, are criminals
under law. While there have been no
prosecutions in recent times, the potential
penalty is up to 10 years’ imprisonment.
The only circumstance which gives
exception to criminality is if a doctor is of
the honest opinion that “the operation
was necessary to preserve the woman
involved from serious danger to her life
or physical or mental health which the
continuance of pregnancy would entail”.
‘Mental health’ has since been interpreted
to include “the effects of economic
or social stress that may pertain either
during pregnancy or after birth”.
Irrespective of this leeway, NSWNMA
general secretary Brett Holmes contends the
12 | nursingreview.com.au
law violates women’s reproductive rights,
infringes on their autonomy, and places an
unfair burden on both patient and provider.
“Abortion is a health issue, not a criminal
issue,” Holmes told Nursing Review.
“Firstly, we believe in the right of patients
to self-determine the health choices they
make. And we particularly believe that
women should have a choice to decide on
medical issues around their own body.”
These women deserve to be cared for
by professional staff, he continued, who do
not feel they are risking their professional
or personal lives by assisting a patient in
need. This encompasses not only the
risk of criminal prosecution, but “their
right to provide services and expertise”.
Indirectly, those involved in ethical
abortion procedures may be emotionally,
professionally and psychologically
harmed through social persecution,
whether that be “intimidation or threats
of attacks from well-meaning but
misguided people trying to change minds
that have been already made up”.
Safety and privacy measures to mitigate
this harm were introduced last year, when
NSW parliament made it illegal for protesters
to harass people within 150 metres of clinics
and hospitals that provide terminations.
Under the current arrangements, NSW
nurses approached by women seeking
abortion must refer them to another service
– the vast majority of which are privately
run. This, said Holmes, further punishes
and alienates both women from lower
socioeconomic backgrounds, and women
living in regional or remote communities.
To afford this private service, and
potentially the travel cost on top of it, such
women may be forced to negotiate a loan
from Centrelink. This notoriously impersonal
and occasionally bungling bureaucratic
program subsequently becomes the arbiter
of this very personal choice at an intensely
time-sensitive and pivotal moment.
“If they’re unemployed, then they’ve got
to spend months, if not years, paying that
advanced payment back,” Holmes said.
“This is a cruel way to deal with people
in crisis … While the legislation doesn’t
guarantee that that would occur, the public
health system seems to have de-risked itself
by not undertaking this health procedure.
“Any woman who has to make this choice
shouldn’t be unnecessarily punished or
impeded by our laws or our health system.”
The debate around abortion has flared up
in recent months, as states across America
take a progressively hardline approach on
the issue, emboldened by a Supreme Court
newly weighted with conservative justices.
Four US states have so far adopted the
‘heartbeat bill’, which bans abortion before
a woman may be aware she is pregnant.
As reported by the Chicago Tribune, in
Ohio, an 11-year-old carrying her rapist’s
child is not eligible for the procedure.
Alabama’s Human Life Protection Act, signed
in May, bans abortion completely, even
in the case of rape or incest. Any doctor
who performs an abortion there could be
sentenced to up to 99 years behind bars.
Holmes acknowledged that in
Australia’s last conservative pro-life
stronghold, the issue remains divisive.
One NSWNMA member resigned after
the association made its stance clear.
“But it comes down to principles about
choice and rights and dignity of people,”
Holmes said. “Principles are principles, and
hopefully more people will join than leave.”
He is also convinced that the majority
of the public would like to see the
legislation brought into the 21st century,
with parliament reflecting a minority
of “louder voices who are passionately
against giving women the choice on
how to manage their own bodies”.
This view is backed by research conducted
by the University of Sydney and James Cook
University in September last year, through
a survey involving 1000 NSW residents.
Seventy-three per cent of respondents
thought abortion should be decriminalised
and regulated as a healthcare service.
The survey also found, however, that
76 per cent of respondents were unaware
that abortion is a criminal offence in NSW.
One in three Australian women will have
an abortion in their lifetime, with 80,000
carried out each year across the country. ■