industry & reform
that is navigable by the average client is
basically absurd.”
Flicker was asked what he would include
if he could have a wish list of reforms that
the royal commission could propose.
Navigators for the My Aged Care system
was one wish. Another was Aboriginal
owned and operated aged care facilities.
“My last wish is supporting the traditional
roles of the elders, which is part of the Uluru
Statement.”
PERTH: JAPARA CEO UNDER
THE SPOTLIGHT
One hundred assaults over four-and-a-half
years is not evidence of systemic issues
among staff, according to Mark Sudholz,
chief executive of aged care provider Japara.
Sudholz appeared uncomfortable at
the recent Perth hearing, and by the end
of his testimony he was visibly upset. He
was taken to task regarding the incidents
reported the previous day concerning the
assault of Noleen Hausler’s father Clarence
at a Japara facility in 2015.
He and the senior counsel assisting the
commission, Peter Rozen, went back and
forth over Japara’s definition of ‘rough
handling’. They also couldn’t agree on a
definition of the word ‘vexatious’, which
Sudholz used to describe Hausler.
In an email to his board, Sudholz wrote:
“Hi all, you will be pleased to hear that we
have achieved 100 per cent occupancy at
Mitcham ACF for the first time ever despite
the ongoing complaints and vexatious
approach by Noleen Hausler and her
activist group.”
Sudholz was also asked about another
email in which he seemed to imply that
Hausler’s complaints were financially
motivated.
“This has been about financial gain to
her, and the action she has taken is for the
The idea that this is
a system that is navigable
by the average client is
basically absurd.
purpose of putting us under pressure and
forcing a settlement, which we will not do,”
the email to a senior employee said.
Most surprisingly were his statements
regarding the prevalence of assault across
Japara’s 49 facilities.
Rozen quizzed Sudholz over the 298
allegations of assault and the process of
investigation used by Japara.
Sudholz replied that they were “alleged”
assaults and that the number of actual
assaults was much less.
“The number at the moment that I
understand is under 100. And under that
basis, it isn’t 298 assaults that Japara has
had over four-and-a-half years. It is a figure
much less than that,” he said.
As his testimony ended, he was at pains
to apologise to Hausler and teared up as he
did so.
being away from her homeland, magnified
as she is the eldest in her family.
“My heart is crying, yes. My heart is crying
because I far away from my family. Because
if I pass away here, I’ve got my spirit, my
culture, my ceremony way back home at
They drive me, put me
on the ambulance ... and I
didn’t know this place, and
I was crying for four weeks.
DARWIN: ‘MY HEART IS CRYING’
The royal commission hearing in Darwin
looked at aspects of care in residential,
home and flexible aged care, as well as
the issues faced by those living in rural and
remote communities.
Day one opened with testimony from
Dr Meredith Hansen-Knarhoi, a GP who
visits the Terrace Gardens aged care
facility in Darwin, and her patient Mildred
Numamurdirdi, an elder and traditional
owner from Numbulwar.
Hansen-Knarhoi met Numamurdirdi
in 2018 when she was moved from
Numbulwar, about 800km from Darwin,
after a stint in hospital due to pneumonia.
Hansen-Knarhoi told the commission that
Numamurdirdi has been unable to return to
her community and that the nearest aged
care facility is a five to six-hour drive away.
This has left Numamurdirdi isolated from
family, friends and, importantly, her culture.
Numbulwar has a small population of
about 750, but this can swell up to 1500
depending on community events, funerals
or football matches.
“They drive me, put me on the
ambulance, and they drive me, and I didn’t
know this place, and I was crying for four
weeks… sad for my family,” Numamurdirdi
said via pre-recorded video testimony.
Terrace Gardens is too far for her
daughter and grandsons to visit, with
dangerous dirt roads and “lots of accident
along the road”.
She talked of her life before she moved
to Darwin when her “family never missed
me”. They used to surround her, sit with her,
talk and laugh with her. Her family would
eat damper and whatever they had hunted,
“sharing, family sharing”.
“They love me so much and I love them
so much, my children and my grandkids,”
she said.
Numamurdirdi described to the
commission the spiritual hurt she endures
home and my family, they don’t want that
way, because we’ve got everything there in
the home,” she said.
“I’m the eldest out of my family and that’s
my motherland, Numbulwar.”
She misses the freedom of her home,
and of things like going to the beach in her
wheelchair.
“We don’t have aged care closer … in our
community. I’m asking to build aged care in
our community … please,” she said.
Kim McRae, team manager at
Ngaanyatjarra Pitjantjatjara Yankunytjatjara
(NPY) Women’s Council (Aboriginal
Corporation), tries to facilitate Indigenous
clients’ wishes to remain on country.
“We do a lot of advocacy for people
around their desire to continue living on
country,” she said. “At times, that puts
us a little bit at odds with other service
providers who may feel it would be more
appropriate for someone to live in town
and get additional supports,” she told
the commission.
McRae suggested more needs to be done
to help people return to country for cultural
events (if a move to city care is needed)
through better funding, and this will result in
better health outcomes for the patient.
“I think return to country is really critical to
people’s emotional and social wellbeing.
“The difficulty is the threshold around
where someone’s care needs have
increased and yet they’re still saying they
want to continue to live on country. There’s
a tipping point, I guess, where perhaps the
medical service is starting to be concerned
about that person.”
McRae often helps residents visit home
when she has reason to drive “out bush”, be
it a festival or outreach program, but it is not
always possible.
“Actually finding specific funding for
that to occur is getting harder and harder,”
McRae said. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 9