clinical practice
What other figures are there around the prevalence of violence
against transgender people?
We have documentation of more than 2100 murders of
transgender people, worldwide, in the last eight years. And as you
might imagine, across much of the world, these murders go on
without being properly documented. Many transgender people,
particularly transgender women, get involved in sex work, as a way
of simply surviving, putting food on the table. They don’t take care
of themselves. That’s part of that psychological and emotional
wellbeing issue. As a result, the HIV rate for transgender women
worldwide is 49 times higher than for the general population.
That gives you some sort of idea. Across the world, transgender
people are facing big challenges in relation to living a life with
dignity and enjoying the same opportunities the rest of us enjoy
without even thinking about it. It’s a situation that needs to change.
In the paper, you highlight what you refer to as the
‘stigma-sickness slope’. Are these the sort of things that
term describes?
Yes, that’s a good way of describing the circumstances in which
many transgender people live, worldwide. There are some places
that are worse than others. Australia’s not perfect, by any means;
transgender people experience difficulties here, too. But in other
parts of the world, things can be [even worse]. The levels of
violence against transgender women in Brazil, for example, and
across much of Latin America, are appalling. In places such as
Malaysia, transgender people can be prosecuted and imprisoned
simply for, in the authorities’ view, cross-dressing. But [in real
terms, they’re being prosecuted for] wearing the clothes that
match their experience of themselves.
You’ve said transgender people’s access to healthcare is
complicated by the fact that, at present, their experiences are
conceptualised as a mental disorder. What issues arise from
this classification, even in countries like Australia, and what
would you like to see changed?
The conceptualisation of the transgender
experience as a mental disorder serves, in
some ways, to trivialise their experience.
The HIV rate
Across much of the world, health
for transgender
insurance won’t cover mental issues.
women is 49 times Even where health services are
available to transgender people, this
higher than
idea that they’re suffering from some
average
sort of mental disorder complicates
their ability to [have a say about] their
own healthcare. They don’t get the same
opportunities to make these decisions about
their healthcare that most of us would, because they’re seen, in
some way, as mentally disordered.
In another of your papers, titled “Synergies in health and human
rights: A call to action to improve transgender health”, you set
out some steps to improve health and wellbeing for transgender
people. What are some of the key measures governments and
healthcare providers need to adopt or consider?
There are so many. One is to ensure that healthcare providers
learn about transgender people and their needs when they’re
training. That’s important, not just for specialists. We’re not taking
about psychiatrists here, we’re talking about primary healthcare
providers, family doctors and frontline nurses. They all need to
know more about transgender people’s needs.
At a different level in the health system, the [World Health
Organization] needs to think in a new way about transgender people
– and it is starting to do that. At the moment, transgender people
are seen as suffering from a mental disorder but the WHO is revising
its diagnostic manual. That manual should come out, we hope, in
2018. When it does, we hope it will consider transgender people as
experiencing a medical condition related to their sexual health.
From that point on, we hope transgender people will not be
seen anymore as suffering from a mental disorder. That would be
a big step forward.
What are some of the key messages you hope healthcare
professionals take away from your paper?
That transgender people are simply different. They’re not
disordered, they’re not unnatural, they’re not sinful. They’re not
deceivers or pretenders. They’re simply different. Diversity is a
great thing. We can – we should – be able to live with diversity.
We should even, perhaps, be able to celebrate it. Transgender
people are part of that amazing thing called human diversity. I’d
like [health professionals] to go away with that message and think
about the implications of that message.
You’ve said that more training and education are needed for
healthcare professionals, to raise awareness