workforce
Take it easy
Mindfulness experts talk about stress reduction.
Desley Hegney and Mark Craigie interviewed by Conor Burke
N
urse retention is a constant battle in healthcare. It has been
estimated that replacing one registered nurse can cost
anywhere between $17,728 and $104,686.
The high-stress environment affects every nurse differently. Some
will experience negative outcomes, such as burnout and traumatic
stress, while others, known as ‘resilient’ people, will be able to adapt
to this environment.
Higher resilience is directly linked to nurse retention, and
researchers have been trying to find ways to impart resilience on
the workforce as a whole. To this end, Professor Desley Hegney
of CQUniversity and clinical psychologist Dr Mark Craigie have
developed a self-care and resiliency intervention based on
mindfulness. Originating in Western Australia, it consists of a
one‑day compassion fatigue prevention workshop, followed by
weekly mindfulness training seminars.
Before the workshop, participants showed a 45 per cent burnout
rate compared to 15 per cent after completing the training.
“I wish I’d done it six months earlier because I might not have got in
the hole that I got into at the beginning of this year,” said one nurse.
Another described her stress levels after the training: “You need
this done and that done and it’s got to be done yesterday – and
there are lots of demands. I can run around like a mad chook with
my head cut off and try to satisfy everybody’s needs and become
more frustrated and more unhappy, or I can take a few deep
breaths, take a couple of minutes, do a little mindfulness exercise
and then think, ‘Okay, what’s the biggest priority?’”
Nursing Review spoke to Hegney and Craigie to hear more about
the training and how we can all relax.
NR: Professor Hegney, tell us about your work at CQUniversity.
DH: I head up the International Consortium of Occupational
Resilience. There’s always been a concern about workforce
26 | nursingreview.com.au
shortages in the longer term, and certainly with the health
workforce predicting some fairly large shortages of nurses by 2025.
There’s always been attrition, particularly within the first five years
of working in the nursing profession. I’d done quite a lot of nursing
workforce research prior to coming into this area. What we wanted
to investigate at [Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital] in Perth was the
wellbeing and resilience of the nursing workforce.
[Charles Gairdner] is a magnet hospital, and as such has a
particular focus on the wellbeing of the nursing workforce. It also
has a huge focus on nursing research.
We surveyed the staff who work in what we consider high-risk
areas – such as the emergency department, intensive care, and
medical/surgical wards where there is a high number of older
people with dementia – and we found that about 25 per cent had
compassion fatigue.
Compassion fatigue is a concept that’s made up of two sub-
concepts. One is secondary traumatic stress, or vicarious stress.
That’s like having post-traumatic stress, but the stress comes from
caring for people who are traumatised. You’re not actually being
traumatised yourself, primarily, it’s a secondary traumatisation.
The other component is burnout.
Twenty-five per cent of nurses had some abnormal level
of compassion fatigue. On the positive side, 25 per cent had
compassion satisfaction.
We found that the people who had compassion satisfaction,
which is the good thing you get when you look after people, were
more likely to be nurses who’d been in the workforce longer.
The ones who were more at risk were those who’d been in
the workforce for a shorter period of time, and also had fewer
postgraduate qualifications. So there was a component of being
prepared for the work that you’re doing to a certain extent.
We then decided to look at all the nurses in the hospital. There
was no difference. It didn’t matter where you worked in the hospital,
the percentage of nurses were the same. It was about 25 per cent.
We worked in collaboration with Dr Mark Craigie. He has his own
private practice, but he also works at one of the psych hospitals
in Perth. We sat down with the nurses and Mark and designed
a program we call the Mindful Self-Care and Resiliency (MSCR)
program, and we ran that initially with the senior staff.
Then we put them into a wait list control trial. We couldn’t do a
randomised control trial ethically, because we already had evidence
that the program was effective. We also followed them up for six
months. We found that the program was effective in reducing levels
of secondary traumatic stress, burnout and so on, and keeping
these levels down – which was important.