workforce
Barriers to rural care
primary nurse practitioner informants, who
were also invited to nominate up to two
colleagues as secondary informants.
Nursing Review spoke with Smith to
hear more about the barriers and enablers
affecting practice.
Nurse practitioners in
the bush are struggling
to provide best care.
Tony Smith interviewed by Conor Burke
R
ural nurse practitioners are facing a
number of hurdles when it comes
to delivering the best care possible.
This is the opinion of a new study
looking into extended scopes of practice
in rural settings, carried out by researchers
from the University of Newcastle’s
Department of Rural Health.
Legal and regulatory barriers occur and
slow down the system in these areas, as
does ambiguity around the scope of the
NP role itself.
Associate Professor Tony Smith said his
team observed a number of health service
gaps, and as Australia seems to have few
developed extended scope practice roles,
NPs are great case studies to use.
“Certainly this has been raised before,
not just by myself but by others, such
as the Grattan Institute and even the
Productivity Commission,” Smith said.
“You know, we’re going back to 2005,
when the Productivity Commission did an
extensive analysis of the Australian health
workforce. They drew similar conclusions
that we needed to actually have a close
look at some of these barriers.
“Now we’re almost 15 years on and I
think we’re still struggling with some of the
same issues we were struggling with then.”
Smith and his team conducted semi-
structured, in-depth interviews with
NR: The nurse practitioner (NP) model
was introduced to address health service
gaps. However, its sustainability has been
questioned. What did you find when you
interviewed NPs in rural settings?
TS: For the most part, we found that the
NP role is valued and makes a significant
contribution in communities where it
exists. But only about 0.5 per cent of the
nursing workforce are endorsed as NPs,
and only a very small proportion of those
are in rural and remote areas. It was in
those areas that the idea of NPs was really
born. The idea was to fill gaps where there
was a lack of service availability due to
small numbers of medical practitioners and
other health professionals.
Despite the positives, we found
significant barriers that prevented the
implementation of the NP role. These
barriers are difficult to overcome because
they’re often legislative or regulatory in the
way they’re constructed.
Examples provided by the interviewees
were the Medicare Benefits Schedule and
the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme, where
there are limitations on who can actually do
what in terms of providing services, and the
amount of income that can be generated
via those Medicare benefits.
There are also limitations on the types
of medications that can be prescribed by
NPs. One of the interviewees said they
were only able to generate a very small
amount of income for their health service
through their Medicare benefits through
bulk-billing.
Another thing highlighted was the
disconnect between Commonwealth and
state policies. Often, there were incentives
that existed at a Commonwealth level that
weren’t necessarily followed up at the state
level in terms of legislation and vice versa.
For example, the types of medications
that are able to be prescribed by NPs are
legislated on a state-by-state basis. So even
though the Medicare benefits legislation
exists at the Commonwealth level, states
make decisions about what types of
medications can be prescribed by non-
medical practitioners. This is a barrier to
the way these roles function.
You also found that community, patient
and manager attitudes were sometimes a
barrier to the full use of NPs.
That was really interesting. A lot of
interviewees had comments about the fact
that their communities were supportive
of the role. They thought it was great to
have an NP in their community who could
provide services when they couldn’t get
a doctor. However, there was also a gap in
the understanding that the community had
about the roles and what sorts of services
could be provided by the NPs.
It seems that there needs to be more
promotion and greater transparency
about what these roles involve so that
the community can access these services
more readily.
Several of the NPs were saying they
spend a fair bit of time promoting their role
and trying to explain it. And not just to the
general public, but to their professional
colleagues, be they doctors, nurses or
allied health practitioners.
It also seems that, in some cases, roles
were implemented without a clear position
description, so it was up to the incumbent,
the person who stepped into that role as an
endorsed educated NP, to then define their
role. In the view of some of the informants,
this seemed to be a little back-to-front. The
time could’ve been better spent delivering
services to patients in rural communities.
How can we address these barriers at a
government level?
In many ways, it’s not so much a matter of
the distribution of healthcare practitioners
in rural and remote areas that is lacking, it’s
the distribution of service availability.
Rather than trying to increase the
number of GPs in rural communities, we
should ask what services might be provided
by the existing health service workforce.
Not just nurses, but also allied health
practitioners.
We need to invest in ways to better utilise
the health workforce we have. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 23