clinical practice
Complex questions
What does it mean to
have compassion?
By Conor Burke
F
or Dr Anne O’Callaghan, it started
about 15 years ago when
complications occurred after her
cancer surgery.
“I couldn’t get anybody to hear that I was
worried about my paralysed legs and my
pain,” she says. “And I think I was labelled as
a difficult healthcare professional.”
The compassion was lacking. But when
she thinks back to that time, it’s a new grad
nurse who sticks out for O’Callaghan. She
doesn’t remember exactly what that nurse
did – it was just small acts of kindness
– but it transformed her memory of
suffering.
It often takes a personal experience
to shape your outlook on life and work.
O’Callaghan is a palliative medicine
specialist at Auckland Hospital and teaches
at the University of Auckland, and time
after time she has witnessed a lack of
compassion for patients in her peers.
“Compassion is a complex concept,”
she says.
In fact, sympathy, empathy and
compassion are different things, she adds.
“Sympathy’s often seen as a distancing
kind of thing, where the person who’s giving
the sympathy is not actually standing very
close alongside the person who’s suffering,”
she says.
“Sometimes it’s seen as unhelpful by the
person who’s experiencing it.”
20 | nursingreview.com.au
Empathy, she says, involves walking in
someone else’s shoes and revealing more
vulnerability on the part of the doctor
or nurse.
Whereas compassion, although it
involves empathy, is more of a will or desire
to act to relieve someone’s suffering, and
like that grad nurse from O’Callaghan’s
past, it often involves those small acts
of kindness that are above and beyond
the job.
ANOTHER CASE, ANOTHER NUMBER
Putting yourself in the shoes of a doctor
or a nurse, it would be easy to think of
patients as cases. So many people come
through the doors every day, and in terms
of self-preservation, being emotionally
detached could work for some.
“Historically, doctors have been trained
to be dispassionate as opposed to
compassionate. To put feelings to one side
and look at facts and the objective.
“That is changing in medical schools.
Issues of self-awareness, affection,
emotions and compassion are now talked
about and are part of the discourse. So,
that’s an encouraging change.”
O’Callaghan looks at it from a
neuroscience perspective. From brain
imaging, scientists have found that
different parts of the brain are activated
when we experience these things.
“There’s something about empathy that
can switch on bits of the brain associated
with aversion and negative states, whereas
compassion switches on bits of the brain
associated with reward and positive states.
“So, that does fit with the idea that
people can get overwhelmed, [especially if
they] sit day after day hearing really difficult
stories and have no means to alleviate that
suffering,” she says.
When asked how compassionate fatigue
comes into play, O’Callaghan replies that
‘empathic distress’ is a more accurate
term. The caregiver becomes so involved
in a patient’s suffering that it becomes
unhealthy, and they shut down or withdraw.
So, how do we help the health
professionals to better help the patients?
PHILOSOPHICAL THINKING
“How do we fix this system and flourish
as human beings?” O’Callaghan
wonders aloud. “And how can we have
environments in which everyone can
flourish and heal to whatever extent
they’re able to?”
In the next breath we are talking about
Zen Buddhism.
“There’s a social anthropologist called
Joan Halifax, who’s a Zen Buddhist and
works in the Upaya Zen Centre in Santa Fe
[New Mexico, USA]. She’s done work in
Nepal, and she has also worked with the
Dalai Lama and with neuroscientists,
and she’s tried to bring together all these
different facets to look really deeply at
what makes compassion, and what can
help us be more compassionate.
“And she’s got a lovely little model called
the GRACE model, which is a way that
any individual could quite quickly help
themselves to get into a compassionate
state within our person.”