Legal Corner
And later he posted:
“If my marriage fell apart, it would not end in divorce.
It would end in murder.”
No hiding online
Healthcare professionals
need to maintain society’s
expectations even when
posting online.
By Scott Trueman
W
hen nurses use social media, whether at home or
at work, they need to be aware of their professional
obligations. Their online behaviour is governed by the
Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia’s codes of conduct and
ethics, as well as the Australian Health Professional Regulation
Agency’s social media policy.
A recent disciplinary hearing highlights what can happen
when social media posts bring the profession and the individual
into disrepute. While it relates to the actions of a medical
practitioner, it is also applicable to nurses.
The case concerns a medical practitioner, Dr L, who made
inappropriate statements and comments in posts on overseas
online forums and chat sites, starting in 2016.
Dr L was readily, from his own words and photographs,
identifiable as an Australian medical practitioner. His online
comments included the following:
“I beg to differ. This kind will NEVER learn. She needs
to be abandoned in India and repeatedly raped...”
“I am a medical practitioner. I also have a foul mouth
and call a spade a spade.”
“I can just as easily condemn your mother for a whore
(if the situation warranted it) as I can save your life...”
“Nah, I’m a lesbian in mind only ... I just need some alcohol.”
“With her suicide, nothing of value would be lost.”
In 2017, referring to an article about an Egyptian lawyer who was
sentenced to three years in prison for saying that women who wear
ripped jeans should be raped as punishment, Dr L posted:
“I’m surprised they didn’t give him a medal instead.”
In 2018 Dr L described himself as follows:
“A mongrel doctor who claims to know all manner
of shit on earth. He works and resides in Australia ...
There’s some tiagong [sic] that he was forced into the
marriage because his wife had threatened to report
him to police for raping her, after he spiked her curry
then upped her after their graduation prom night.”
14 | nursingreview.com.au
At the time of the disciplinary hearing in 2019, Dr L was aged 31.
He submitted in mitigation that none of his sociopolitical and
other personal views coloured or influenced his medical practice.
Further, Dr L submitted that he did not fully appreciate that
posting comments on a Singaporean online forum would have
consequences on his practice of medicine in Australia and that
they were made, “not in the practice of medicine” and after hours.
The tribunal found that Dr L understood that the posts could
be perceived as inflammatory, misogynistic and racist in tone
and that the posts were clearly associated to him. It was clear
from the posts and the photographs he posted that he was a
registered medical practitioner from Australia.
The tribunal also found that the posts conveyed socially
unacceptable and extreme sentiments that were disrespectful
of women and commented upon violence towards or sexual
abuse of women:
“Some of the online posts might reasonably be
interpreted as being racially discriminatory contrary
to acceptable social norms in Australia. All of the
online posts had the potential to incite radical views,
antagonise the reader, and they had the potential to
cause harm to the public. In addition, some of the
posts involved the use of vulgar language, expressions
of committing violence and crime, all of which
are inconsistent with the good repute of medical
practitioners and the relationship of trust between
medical practitioners and patients who are, of course,
members of the public.”
The tribunal found in relation to penalty that:
“The conduct is serious and does amount to
professional misconduct. Accordingly, a strong
sanction is necessary in order to send a message to
both the respondent [Dr L] and doctors broadly that
they need to be circumspect and they must abide by
the professional behaviours required of them in the
code and the social media policy.”
The tribunal stated that the conduct amounted to professional
misconduct pursuant to the National Law. Insofar as penalty
was concerned, the tribunal ordered:
(a) that Dr L be reprimanded
(b) that he be suspended from practising for six weeks
(c) that he be required to undertake education on ethical
behaviour and communications, particularly in the use of
social media.
This case demonstrates that even if posting on overseas forums,
when physically overseas, when not in the course of employment
and when on your own computer, it can still amount to
professional misconduct.
These clearly offensive posts fall well below the standard set
by both the profession and the public of what they expect of a
health professional.
What was egregious in this matter was the associated posted
photographs that linked the author to his name, degree of
specialty, his employment and his health service employer.
Remember, what you post on social media, no matter where,
is literally broadcast to the world at large. ■