industry & reform
Merle Mitchell
gives evidence via
video. Photo: AAP/
Royal Commission
No voice, no choice
A summary of the third
round of the aged care
royal commission’s
hearings in Sydney, which
focused on dementia.
By Conor Burke
D
arryl Hilda Melchhart, a sharp-
minded 90-year-old who has lived
in residential aged care since 2014,
was the first to take the stand in Sydney at
the hearings of the Royal Commission into
Aged Care Quality and Safety.
Inside a small courtroom, she spoke to
the many problems within residential care
as she sees it, from rationed incontinence
pads, to bland food, to loneliness.
Melchhart groaned when prompted to
talk about the problems she faces when
asking nurses for simple things such as
getting her medical paperwork ready for
the cardiologist.
More shocking were her recollections
of the violence she faced at the hands of
other residents on the ward, where, in her
estimate, only 10 of the 90 residents have
their full faculties.
One incident saw a resident come into
Melchhart’s room to steal her jewellery
box. When confronted, the resident
attacked her with a mug.
Melchhart has spoken to staff about all of
these issues, she said, but she feels as if she
has “no voice”.
When she alerted a nurse to her expiring
GTN spray, which she needs for a heart
condition, she said the nurse refused to
10 | nursingreview.com.au
grant her a new one and took the depleted
spray away. This left her without this
potential life-saver for nearly four days,
until her doctor intervened.
Another aged care resident, Merle
Mitchell, AM, gave evidence via a pre-
recorded video. She told the court of the
“terrible” time she had transitioning from an
independent life to an “institution”. She felt
she had “no choice” but to conform to the
strict schedules imposed upon her.
Like Melchhart, Mitchell recounted her
own near-death experience. “Three senior
people” ignored Mitchell’s complaints of
pain, telling her “it is all in your head”.
Only when a fellow resident warned
nurses that they were at risk of committing
elder abuse was Mitchell taken to hospital,
she said.
She was found to have a crushed disc
and broken back.
When asked whether she felt that staff
are adequately trained to provide care,
Mitchell gave a blunt “no”.
And if she could nominate one thing to
change in the sector?
“Ratios, ratios, ratios. Everybody will tell
you that.”
‘NO LONGER THE MAN HE WAS’
Drugged without family consent and
strapped to a chair for hours on end,
Terrence Reeves spent a hellish 60 days
in Garden View aged care facility, the
royal commission was told.
Wife Lillian and daughters Michelle
McCulla and Natalie Smith recounted
how an otherwise fit Reeves entered the
Garden View facility on a short respite with
dementia, and at that point was still able
to shower himself and get around with
Lillian’s help.
Lillian and her daughters were
approached by staff about signing a
restraint form for Reeves for short periods,
as they “felt that during changeover shift
there weren’t a lot of people that would be
watching him, and that it would be for his
own safety”.
However, in McCulla’s testimony, the
court heard that on nearly 30 occasions
family members turned up to find Reeves
restrained, sometimes in a secure dementia
wing with many other patients strapped to
chairs in a small room.
On nearly every other visit to the
facility, McCulla or other family members
found Reeves tied down, she said, and
in one instance found him “drooling” and
“shivering”, barefoot and wearing only a
singlet wet with saliva.
Reeves was also wet from incontinence
that day, and McCulla recounts hearing
his screams as he was changed by six
nurses all pulling at separate limbs trying
to undress him.
“Dad grabbed my arm and said, ‘How
would you like it?’” McCulla said.
Lillian told the commission that at no
point did she mention to Garden View
staff that she ever gave her husband
risperidone, nor did she ever consent
to him being administered the drug by
Garden View staff.
However, the women were convinced
that their father was being medicated.
McCulla remembered an occasion
when the whole family brought a home-
cooked lunch to Reeves. They found him
unconscious, she said, but were told he
was asleep.
As they tried to rouse him, he started to
gag. McCulla found a piece of meat lodged
in his throat. She cleared the obstruction
and lifted him up to continue rousing him,
only to find he had faeces smeared all
along his back.
There was then a disagreement between
the family and Garden View as to whether
Reeves had been medicated.
According to notes presented to the
commission, Reeves was regularly given
a dose of risperidone, which staff say had
been approved by Lilian.
However, the family say this is not the
case, and when they confronted staff that
day, they were told Reeves had not been
given the drug in about a month.
“They said, ‘No, no, look at his charts.’
I was convinced that it was risperidone,”
McCulla said.