workforce
Be a leader
How nurses
can be more
influential on
health policy.
Diana Mason
interviewed by
Dallas Bastian
B
e bold. Be visible. Be a leader.
The former president of the
American Academy of Nursing, Dr
Diana Mason, challenged Australian nurses
to this ahead of her keynote presentation at
the recent 2018 ACN Policy Summit.
The event was held to recognise that
while nurses are admired by patients
for their work, they are still battling for
comprehensive consultation on healthcare
issues. The summit aimed to offer nurses a
seat at the policymaking table.
It also set out the priority areas of healthy
ageing, workforce sustainability, end of life
care and chronic diseases.
Mason, who is currently co-director of
the new Center for Health Policy and Media
Engagement at the George Washington
University School of Nursing, walked
attendees through the ways in which they
can use their voice to shape the future of
Australian services and public health.
Nursing Review spoke with Mason ahead
of the event to discover the differences
between the US and Australian health
systems and how nurse-designed models
of care stand out.
NR: What do think are the most striking
differences between the health systems?
DM: Well, if you look at a comparative
study – which is done periodically by the US
Commonwealth Fund – the US ranks very
poorly on most of the indicators that look at
24 | nursingreview.com.au
quality of healthcare, access to healthcare,
and outcomes.
On healthcare performance, Australia
ranked second out of these 11 peer
countries, and the US is dead last. Australia
has better care processes, better access to
care and better administrative efficiency.
You have better equity and have better
health outcomes. In fact, you ranked
number one out of these 11 countries on
healthcare outcomes. We rank 11th.
Where the US exceeds other developed
countries is in how much we spend on
healthcare. We spend way more of a
percentage of our gross domestic product
than other countries. In the most recent
2014 data, Australia spent the least of
these 11 countries. The proportion of the
US gross domestic product is around 17
per cent, and yours is about 8 per cent, so
you spend half as much as we do but have
better outcomes.
I think you’re doing quite well. In fact,
I’m going to raise a question tomorrow.
Why am I presenting to you? You should
be presenting to me! But Australia does
have some areas for improvement, and
one is in access to care, and that makes
sense, particularly from the standpoint
of your more remote areas as well as on
equity. You rank seventh on healthcare
equity, and so you still have problems
with socioeconomic differences in the
quality of care.
My conclusion is that you don’t need
much more healthcare at all. I think you
need to improve access in rural areas, but
even there – I live in New York City, but I
spend most of my time in Upstate New York,
a very rural area, and we’re just beginning
to use telemedicine there. You’ve been way
ahead of the curve on that.
My argument is that more healthcare is
not necessarily the answer. Nurses need
to be turning their attention to the social
determinants of health. Nurses need to
get more involved and outspoken on the
connection between health and education,
business development, economic
development and health, transportation
and health, access to healthy foods
and health. I’m really trying to push this
message in the US, that we’ve bought into
the fact that we think healthcare systems
are what promotes health, and they don’t
necessarily promote health.
In fact, in the US, medical errors are the
third leading cause of death in the country,
so I really don’t want to enter the healthcare
system if I don’t have to in the US. I don’t
know what your medical error rate is, but I
suspect it’s much better than ours.
What power do nurses have to shape
policy, health systems and beyond?
First of all, nurses have the opportunity to
shape policies at the local level as well as at
the state, territory and federal level by their
vote, by the candidates they support.
Nurses need to be visible with the fact
that they will vote for candidates and
parties that support a policy agenda that
promotes the health of community.
As a nurse, I think the nursing community
needs to have a conversation about
what we believe about health and what
promotes health, and what is the party
that aligns with our interests. In the US,
nurses are the largest group of health
professionals – I believe it’s the same in
Australia – and if nurses make it known that
we are going use our vote to elect parties
and candidates who support health and
health of community, that’s very powerful.
I also think nurses need to run for office,
and to hold local, state and national offices,
and seek appointments by government and
by other entities, and to insist that nurses
are at all decision-making tables that have
anything to do with health.
Think about your rural areas and where
transportation may be a problem – that
may be a barrier to healthcare. Who better
than a nurse to sit on the commission
that’s looking to improve transportation
in a rural area? The nurse understands the
importance of that transportation to getting
access to healthcare.
Also, we know that education is a strong
predictor of