Nursing Review Issue 3 | May-Jun 2018 | Page 20

clinical practice was a really significant impact with the attitude towards training and organisational change. So ensuring that people involved in the planning process know exactly what it’ s for and what the outcomes need to be, and then are able to take that training back to an environment where it can be conducive to increasing job performance.
clinical practice was a really significant impact with the attitude towards training and organisational change. So ensuring that people involved in the planning process know exactly what it’ s for and what the outcomes need to be, and then are able to take that training back to an environment where it can be conducive to increasing job performance.

Managing nurses

Training not a fix-all, study says.
Joanna Carlisle interviewed by Dallas Bastian

A holistic approach is best when it comes to managing the job performance of nurses, a researcher has argued.

Charles Sturt University PhD candidate Joanna Carlisle explored the factors that might influence a nurse’ s job performance, such as work environment, attitude towards organisational change, training effectiveness, organisational citizenship behaviour, non-mandatory training and intention to quit.
Carlisle said her thesis, supervised by Associate Professor Ramudu Bhanugopan, revealed that significant relationships exist between many of these factors and indicate the importance of an allencompassing approach when managing job performance.
For example, the study found that the relationship between effective on-the-job training and performance is significantly affected by the hospital work environment.
“ This means a negative work environment could result in training not providing any improvement to nurses’ performance, no matter how effectively it is delivered,” Carlisle said.
The attitude of nurses to organisational change, whether positive or negative, also alters the level of their job performance, but Carlisle found that the effectiveness of training provided by hospitals influences how large this impact is.
“ This study offers a number of contributions and significant implications for nurses in Australian hospitals and health organisations in general,” she said, and added industry seems to regard training and development as the go-to fix-it response for poor performance.
Nursing Review spoke with Carlisle about the factors that positively and negatively influenced job performance and what a truly holistic approach to its management would involve.
NR: What aspects of job performance did you drill down into? JC: I looked into the two focus points of job performance, the task performance and the context performance. My main focus was how attitude towards organisational change, training effectiveness and the factors involved in a work environment impact job performance.
What were some of the factors that determined the impact of training on job performance? I actually found there was a big impact of work environment on that relationship between training effectiveness and job performance. While effective training and training at high levels impacts job performance quite positively and will increase job performance, if there’ s a negative environment, that eventually negates that training, leading to it having very little impact on the nurses’ ability to complete their jobs, particularly when it came to the task performance.
What’ s needed to get the most out of onthe-job training? I think a lot of planning needs to go into it. We need to ensure that all parties involved have the right attitude towards it. There
What other factors negatively impacted job performance? Probably the factors that have a direct impact on reducing job performance would be where there was low organisational citizenship behaviour, or where there was a really high intention to quit. Or a cynical attitude towards the organisation and organisational change.
Those negative impacts could be offset by effective training and a positive work environment, but they certainly did have that negative impact.
What made a nurse more likely to want to leave an organisation or workplace? The biggest direct relationship was with the organisational citizenship behaviour. Where the citizenship behaviour was quite low, the intention to quit was quite high. But, it was the context performance that had a big impact on that relationship. It was able to improve the intention to quit, so make nurses more likely to stay with the organisation, even if that organisational citizenship behaviour was low.
What were some of the factors that positively impacted in job performance? The key aspects of that was for the nurses to have an accepting attitude towards the training and towards the organisation. When that was the case, they were more likely to perceive the training as effective and were more likely to report having a positive work environment. That all led to increased job performance.
You mentioned the importance of a holistic approach when managing the job performance of nurses. What would a truly holistic approach look like? I think it would be starting right back at that planning process and looking at all the different avenues that impact that job performance: where they’ re expected to carry out their training, how the training itself is undertaken, and how they perceive that training process and the organisation. I think it really needs to encompass all those avenues that impact the job performance. ■
18 | nursingreview. com. au