news
Anorexia risk
high at 15
Fasting is typically the first
symptom to hit, then exercise
and purging, study finds.
A
delaide woman Arabella was
15 when she started changing
her eating habits and shedding
weight. The active high school student
and keen athlete was diagnosed
with anorexia nervosa two years later,
in 2010.
Arabella’s story is typical of Australians
with anorexia nervosa, who start fasting
at an average age of 15, a study shows.
Subsequent behaviours include exercise at
16 and purging at 17.
Fasting and exercise are the most
common methods of weight control and
typically start at a younger age, interim
data from the world’s largest genetic
investigation into anorexia nervosa shows.
Most concerning, scientists said, is that
only 32 per cent of local study participants
are under the care of a professional.
Pills better with therapy
Combining treatments is most effective against
depression, mental health experts say.
P
eople being treated for moderate
depression should all be offered
sessions with psychotherapists to
help boost their chances of recovery,
Australian mental health experts have said.
Australians are among the largest users
of antidepressants anywhere in the world,
but there has been a growing evidence
questioning their effectiveness.
Experts from the National Centre of
Excellence in Youth Mental Health and
the University of Melbourne said while
antidepressants have a role in treating
depression, combining them with
psychotherapy is more effective than using
either alone.
Offer all patients psychotherapy “and
medication should be considered if
depression is of at least moderate severity,
psychotherapy is refused, or psychotherapy
hasn’t been effective,” Dr Christopher Davey
and professor Andrew Chanen wrote in the
Medical Journal of Australia.
They also recommend doctors
“The fact that an extremely large number
of people living with anorexia are not under
medical supervision is gravely concerning,
given anorexia has the highest death rate
of any mental health illness,” said Australian
Anorexia Nervosa Genetics Initiative (ANGI)
associate investigator professor Tracey
Wade, of Flinders University.
The ANGI study seeks to shed light
on the genes that predispose people to
anorexia nervosa.
Arabella, who is medically classified
as underweight, says she is making
inroads into managing her illness and is
participating in the study to learn whether it
is genetic, environmental or both.
She is one of more than 2400 Australian
volunteers so far and the scientists hope to
get to a total of 3000 blood donors by July.
“This study represents the largest sample of
Australian individuals with anorexia nervosa
to date; information is providing compelling
insights into weight control behaviours, and
the ages at which these behaviours typically
start,” lead Australian study investigator
professor Nicholas Martin said. ■
With AAP.
encourage patients with depression to eat
well and exercise.
Their calls are based on a review of
studies examining the effectiveness of
antidepressants and psychotherapy for
treating adults and children with depression.
Ten per cent of Australian adults take
antidepressants each day, with the usage
rate having doubled since 2000.
Davey and Chanen said several studies
have shown that antidepressants aren’t as
effective as previously thought, with many
suggesting that the “placebo response” can
be a key factor as patients taking medication
automatically expect they will get well.
Studies looking at psychotherapies, such
as cognitive behavioural therapy, have also
found a decline in effectiveness.
“The modest effect sizes for depression
treatments … suggest that combining
treatments might provide the best outcomes
for patients,” Davey and Chanen wrote.
“In adults, the effect of combined
treatment compared with placebo is about
twice that of medication only.
“The effects of psychotherapy
and medication appear to operate
independently of each other, providing a
good rationale for their combination.” ■
With AAP.
nursingreview.com.au | 5