specialty focus
You recorded face-to-face and telephone interviews with
11 students aged 20 or younger, and you
found that they do face some age-related challenges.
What were some of the obstacles or issues you uncovered?
One of the first things that hit us when they were talking to us
was that they got such a shock when they came to orientation.
We have about 100 students come into first year every year.
That’s a little bit more than we have places for, and what
they talked about was coming into a room full of 100 people
and being shocked at how old they were, which we hadn’t
conceptualised, I guess. That led us to think about what that
meant for them.
They talked about coming in and seeing all these oldies and
being unsure. We’ve written another paper about [student]
motivation. Many of the midwifery students are really keyed
up; they’ve done a lot of research, they’re up on what it means
to be a midwife. However, that didn’t prepare them when they
were used to thinking university was going to be full of all young
people. Three-quarters of the cohort are mature-aged women,
many with children.
One of the other things that was challenging for young students
was [our] cohort of women who’d had their own children. You’ve
got a cohort of students who’ve lived through the experience
of childbirth. A lot of young students found that challenging
and confronting, because they felt like, ‘Oh, she knows because
she’s had that experience but I haven’t.’ So they often questioned
[whether they could be good midwives on that basis].
We already knew when they went into clinical practice that
some of our midwifery colleagues weren’t on the same page as
us in terms of thinking [that] it’s fantastic to have these young
students coming who want to be a midwife.
[So some of the younger students] were challenged by many
of our midwifery colleagues who sometimes felt that they didn’t
have enough experience to be in this important space where
women journey through pregnancy, labour and birth, and the
transition to parenting.
Another factor was [their need to] be on call. There were some
young students who didn’t have their licence yet or didn’t have
a car. Some had to catch buses. That presented challenges to
them in terms of getting to where they needed to go to attend a
birth or to do a post-natal visit in the community and not at the
hospital or health facility.
You identified some strategies students use to build
confidence and competence, in both university and the
clinical environment. What were some of the coping
strategies students developed over time?
We know our young people are fantastic with social media. Our
students come into the intensive teaching block and then they
go out into clinical practice. They don’t come back in again. One
of the challenges is how they can build links and relationships
and support networks when they’re not coming back into uni
every week, or every second week. They were hot on using
social media to be able to talk to one another, to provide support.
That was one of the first things they did; they often gravitated to
one another quickly.
They just beavered away and [found that self-belief]. It was just a
matter of them finding the support, using their midwifery lecturers
as well to say: “This is OK, you will get there. Give yourself an
opportunity to be able to learn the language of childbirth.”
While they initially often saw our [overall] cohort being quite
mature and perhaps them not having anything in common with
them, quickly in their clinical facilities they learnt to build close
relationships with one another, so those older students were really
supportive of the younger one and vice versa. They learnt to give
one another something special.
You said the continuity of care experience is fundamental to
young midwife students’ transition to