Nursing Review Issue 2 March-April 2023 | Page 8

news
news

‘ Unacceptable ’

Inquest into St Vincent Hospital after sepsis death .
By NCA NewsWire

The death of pregnant mother could have been prevented if she was given antibiotics at the correct time by a doctor , an inquest has found .

Melbourne-based Annie O ’ Brien , 37 , passed away due to a fatal sepsis infection in August 2017 .
O ’ Brien received antibiotics hours after she attended Holmesglen Private Hospital in Moorabbin .
By the time of her admission to a second hospital after midnight , it was unlikely she could have been saved , State Coroner Judge John Cain said on Tuesday last week .
Cain handed down his findings in the Coroners Court after the two-week inquest into O ’ Brien ’ s death was heard in August last year .
The inquest exposed failures regarding the Toorak lawyer ’ s treatment , who was 18 weeks pregnant when she attended Holmesglen on August 14 with a temperature of 40 , severe back pains , diarrhoea and vomiting .
6 | nursingreview . com . au
She was incorrectly diagnosed with gastro , having eaten a chicken salad with colleagues earlier that day .
It was reported that O ’ Brien deteriorated rapidly after her second admission at St Vincent ’ s Private Hospital and died the next day following a miscarriage .
However , Cain has decided against forwarding the conduct of Dr Hui Shi , who first treated O ’ Brien at Holmesglen , or the conduct of her obstetrician Dr Vicki Nott , who treated her at St Vincent ’ s , onto the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency , despite the wishes of O ’ Brien ’ s father , Dr Brian Moylan .
Cain said Dr Shi , who first saw O ’ Brien at about 8:30pm on August 14 , should have given her antibiotics and considered the possibility of sepsis when her condition deteriorated for a second time at 10:15pm .
At 11:30pm , when O ’ Brien ’ s membrane ruptured , Cain said that Dr Shi should have reviewed O ’ Brien ’ s diagnosis and have administered broad-spectrum antibiotics .
He said while O ’ Brien had her greatest chance of survival if they were administered at 8:30pm , it was still more likely she would have survived if she ’ d received them at 10:15pm or 11:30pm .
Cain said there was an “ unacceptable ” miscommunication between Dr Shi and Dr Nott when it was agreed that , following to her membrane rupture , O ’ Brien would be transferred to St Vincent ’ s and to Dr Nott .
Dr Shi said she had impressed on Dr Nott the severity of O ’ Brien ’ s condition in her two phone calls prior to the transfer , while Dr Nott insisted she had “ no appreciation ” of how sick the patient was .
O ’ Brien arrived at St Vincent ’ s at 12:15am and appeared “ very distressed ,” according to the evidence of a midwife .
When Dr Nott first got to her bedside at 1:30am , O ’ Brien became convinced of the presence of sepsis due to her “ altered state of mind ”.
The first dose of antibiotics wasn ’ t delivered until 2:46am , more than three hours after O ’ Brien ’ s membrane had ruptured , and she died shortly before 2pm that afternoon .
Cain ’ s recommendations included for specific advice on maternal sepsis to be provided in the Safer Care ’ s “ Think Sepsis , Act Fast ” guidelines , and for Safer Care to develop statewide tools assisting in the proper delivery of handover notes . ■