Legal Corner
Net ban
Court curbs
disabled
man’s social
media usage
for his own
protection.
By Scott Trueman
T
his unique case from the UK brings
to light the fine balance courts have
to maintain between a disabled
consumer’s rights and his or her need for
‘protection’ from engaging in risky behaviour.
This is never more so than when the
consumer is assessed as lacking capacity,
which, in this legal sense, means a person
does not have the intellectual and/or
cognitive ability to consider and fully
understand the consequences of their
actions or behaviours.
This recent decision concerns such
matters in relation to social media usage.
The case involved a 21-year-old, ‘AC’, who
identified as a gay male. He had a learning
disability, with an impairment in adaptive
social and executive functioning. If he had
not been provided with support, he would
not have been able to manage his personal
and domestic care needs. He had been in
independent supported living for most of
the past two years, and received extensive
personal social care support.
Concerns about AC’s internet usage first
arose in early 2016 when he was living at
home. His parents found he had used his
Facebook account to share, with unknown
males, intimate photographs and videos of
his genitals.
His social worker said AC’s “compulsion
to communicate with others online seems
to override any concern he may have
for his own safety”. AC had a very low
literacy level. He used the photographs
14 | nursingreview.com.au
and videos, accompanied by short, simple
but indisputably provocative words, to
communicate with other men.
AC’s low literacy had severely impaired
his ability to navigate the internet safely.
He would often visit extreme pornographic
sites by clicking on a series of suggested
links. When unsupervised, he was known
to search compulsively for sites showing
paedophiliac and other illegal sexual activity.
He clearly could not read nor understand
the warnings regarding the content and
safety of such sites.
Further complicating AC’s submissions
to the court were that AC had confided to
a support worker that he had been raped
twice by an identified male adult. An officer
investigating the matter was concerned
that if AC did not change his behaviour, he
too might become a perpetrator of such
offences “due to his lack of understanding
around the subject”.
When these proceedings were issued, it
was known that AC was continuing to find
ways of associating with perpetrators of
sexual exploitation online. On one occasion,
in May 2017, after his own device had been
temporarily withdrawn, he obtained a staff
member’s mobile and accessed over 150
extreme pornography sites.
In April 2018, AC sent unsolicited text
messages to the male who had been
identified as the alleged perpetrator of the
rape referred to above. AC said he did not
know why he had done this, and could
not identify any problems with doing so.
In evaluating this conduct, the community
nurse and social worker drew attention to the
uncertainty about whether AC’s behaviour
revealed a deficit in one of the areas of his
functioning, or whether he was merely
impulsive, risk-taking and/or ‘unwise’.
The clinical psychologist, treating doctor
and community nurse jointly submitted
that AC “does not understand the risks and
benefits which contact with others presents
to him: his learning disability does result
in a lack of understanding which impairs
his ability to weigh the costs and benefits
of contact, although there is a compulsive
element to his behaviours”.
The internet is important for people with
disabilities and/or social communication
problems. It enables ready access to
information, recreation and communities
for those who are restricted in leaving their
homes. The internet and social media
networks offer users with disabilities
opportunities and enhanced autonomy, they
provide a means to express social identity,
and they enable the learning of new skills and
the development of careers. The importance
of creating and maintaining ready access to
electronic and digital technology for people
with disabilities is well recognised – it is
identified as a right within the United Nations
Convention on the Rights of Persons with
Disability (UNCRPD).
Article 9 of the UNCRPD requires states
(UK and Australia are signatories) to take
appropriate measures to enable those
with disabilities to “live independently and
participate fully in all aspects of life” and to
have “access on an equal basis with others
… [to] information and communications
technologies and systems”.
There is also a requirement on states
to eliminate barriers to accessibility for
people with disabilities to “information,
communications and other services”.
Article 21 provides a complementary
provision, for people with disabilities, to
“exercise the right to freedom of expression
and opinion, including the freedom to seek,
receive and impart information and ideas
on an equal basis with others and through
all forms of communication of their choice”
by “encouraging the mass media, including
providers of information through the internet,
to make their services accessible to persons
with disabilities”.
Article 22 enshrines the right to privacy for
people with disabilities.
Here’s the rub: where does the balance sit
between inherent human rights, enshrined
in legislation, and the protection of the
‘vulnerable’ (a state obligation)?
After due consideration, the court came
down on the side of ‘protective court orders’
for consumer AC.
The court pronounced: “In considering
[AC’s] best interests, I have had regard to the
local authority’s draft ‘internet access and
safety’ care plan. This provides for [AC] to
use one of the iPads owned by [the service
provider] for a limited period each day, under
a degree of supervision; his phone contract
is financially capped, and his mobile device
does not have the capability to access
the internet. He has agreed that staff may
check his mobile phone for messages on
a daily basis to support him in dealing with
unwanted text messages, and to ensure
that he is not engaging in inappropriate
communications with others.”
No matter what your general ‘human
rights’ stance is, it is easy to imagine that
in light of AC’s conduct and history, if
something untoward had occurred, the state
would probably be found legally liable in
negligence and/or breach of their statutory
duty towards AC as a vulnerable consumer. ■