industry & reform
hourly care model and a mandated skills mix
of 30 per cent registered nurse, 20 per cent
enrolled nurse and 50 per cent personal
care worker.
“What we think our research clearly
indicates is there’s just a gaping hole in the
Aged Care Act currently in terms of how you
actually staff against genuine care needs in
residential aged care,” Butler said.
DAY 4: RISE IN ‘SERIOUS RISK’
The year after the government stalled aged
care funding, there was a marked increase
in findings of “substandard care that would
impact on the health and wellbeing of a
care recipient”.
During the evidence of the secretary
of the Department of Health, Glenys
Beauchamp, counsel assisting Peter Gray
alluded to a correlation between the
two outcomes.
In 2015–16 the Australian Aged Care
Quality Agency found only two aged care
providers to be a “serious risk”. The following
year, concurrent with the government’s
indexation of the Aged Care Funding
Instrument (ACFI), there were 22 serious risk
findings, and the year after a jump to 61.
Gray asked whether funding levels were
sufficient and if funding freezes impacted
safety standards, but Beauchamp proved
hard to pin down, causing Gray to repeat
the question. Beauchamp suggested
that “it is sufficient for the forward
estimates period”.
We also heard evidence, from data
contained in consumer experience reports
conducted in over 1100 facilities, that 98.3
per cent of aged care residents felt safe.
However, when more closely inspected,
those figures are misleading. Gray pointed
out that in fact the survey was broken
down into categories, and that of the 98.3
per cent, 17.21 per cent of respondents
answered that they felt safe only “most of
the time”.
When asked by commissioner Briggs if
she would feel comfortable putting a loved
one in a facility under current standards,
and if these standards reflected community
ideals, Beauchamp was noncommittal.
“I think the current standards require
a subjective assessment, not necessarily
based on how the client feels and what the
client is experiencing, but I think the new
standards absolutely put the care recipient
at the centre,” she said.
DAY 5: AIR-CON TALK GETS HEATED
The fifth day of the royal commission saw
a set of tense exchanges between counsel
12 | nursingreview.com.au
assisting Dr Timothy McEvoy and Leading
Age Services Australia (LASA) chief executive
Sean Rooney.
Rooney was taken to task by McEvoy
over a number of issues, in particular LASA’s
views on air-conditioning in aged care
facilities. LASA’s submission mentioned
– in reference to the government’s draft
aged care quality standards consultation
paper – the need for “comfortable internal
temperatures”, which “may be interpreted
that all services are required to have
air-conditioning”.
McEvoy pointed out that, in fact, there
was no reference to internal temperatures
to be found in the draft, asking: “Is it the
view of LASA that it’s unnecessary to have
heating or air-conditioning in residential
aged care facilities?”
Rooney replied in the negative, only to be
pursued by McEvoy.
“So, if that’s the case, why was it
suggested that reference to ‘comfortable
internal temperatures’ be removed and ...
why was there a concern?” he asked.
When asked repeatedly whether he and
LASA believe that air-conditioning should be
standard across aged care facilities, Rooney
repeated that heating and cooling should
make residents “comfortable”.
Rooney was asked how this issue came
up and if LASA was lobbied by providers
due to a fear that air-conditioning may be
a requirement.
Rooney replied that the question “must
have been raised by a member at some
point”, causing McEvoy to question – three
times – whether LASA would ever prioritise
the needs of residents at the expense
of providers.
“I would suggest that LASA has always
looked to ensure that we are supporting our
members to deliver the best possible care
that they can,” Rooney replied.
This was not the only time Rooney was
pressed during his testimony. He was also
asked why some LASA members wanted to
change the wording of the Single Aged Care
Quality Framework.
LASA’s statement reports that “some LASA
members have suggested amending Clause
2.3 to remove ‘continuously monitored’ to
replace it with ‘regularly monitored’”.
The clause currently states that: “Care and
services are implemented and continuously
monitored and evaluated for effectiveness.”
McEvoy then proposed that the
amendments sought by LASA might
serve to reduce “the standard required
because there’s no requirement for
continuous monitoring”.
Margot Harker, aged care service recipient, at
the Commonwealth Courts in Adelaide. Photo:
James Elsby, AAP
“Counsel, I would suggest that was not
the intent of the suggested change to the
standards,” Rooney replied.
The issue of ACFI indexation was again
raised. Nicolas Mersiades, director of aged
care at Catholic Health Australia, said the
indexation formula is “particularly harsh” and
is not keeping up with the economy.
Dementia Australia chief executive Maree
McCabe told the commission that by
2056 there will be an estimated 1.1 million
Australians with dementia, adding “there
won’t be anybody that is not impacted in
some way”.
McCabe called for mandatory dementia
training for the 240,000 aged care workers
in Australia.
“Seventy per cent work as personal care
workers, and their Certificate III does not
provide any education around dementia,
not as mandatory or even optional training,”
she said.
DAY 6: DEATH BEFORE RESIDENCY
Some people would rather die than go into
residential aged care facilities.
This is according to UnitingCare Australia’s
Claerwen Little, who told the commission
about the findings from Uniting’s research
into community perceptions of aged care.
They found, among other things, that
although it is in people’s minds, aged care is
not seen as the most pressing issue for the
government to fix.
However, the research did find that
the wider public had a number of
misconceptions about the sector.
“People thought that it was dominated
by the for-profit sector, that … the big for-
profits were making a lot of money out of
aged care,” Little said.
“That it was mostly residential care … And
the sort of nuances of the community home
support program and home care program