industry & reform
Oakden whistleblower Barbara Spriggs and son Clive. Photo: James Elsby, AAP
Speaking is not easy, she cautioned, but
“speaking out lifted the lid” on the abuse
being committed.
Spriggs spent most of her testimony
outlining her views on the changes that
need to occur in the sector.
These include greater accountability,
improved staffing – training, salaries and
ratios – a database for staff who commit
abuse or have complaints made against
them, CCTV in common areas, and better
end-of-life plans.
View from the peaks
The royal treatment
A summary of the first hearing
of the Royal Commission into
Aged Care Quality and Safety.
By Conor Burke
DAY 1: FIRST WITNESSES CALLED
“I’m sure if I had taken Bob to the Royal
Adelaide Hospital in the state he was in, I
would have been reported to the police.”
That’s how Oakden whistleblower
Barbara Spriggs recounted the injuries her
late husband sustained at the infamous
facility, as she gave her witness testimony to
the aged care royal commission.
Spriggs was the first witness to be called
at the commission in Adelaide on Day 1,
and at times she became emotional as
she recalled the pain and suffering her late
husband Robert ‘Bob’ Spriggs went through
and the subsequent anguish felt by her and
her children.
Bob was 66 years old when he died in
July 2016, after a battle with many illnesses,
including Parkinson’s disease. Bob had
two short stays at the Oakden facility in
South Australia, one in January of 2016 and
another in February of the same year which,
according to Spriggs’ testimony, caused
Bob’s health to decline dramatically.
Before Spriggs was brought up to
testify, counsel assisting Peter Gray started
proceedings. In his slow, measured manner,
Gray set out how the next two weeks will
run, saying that these initial hearings will
mainly provide context and background to
10 | nursingreview.com.au
the industry and that he does not expect the
commissioners to rule on them.
He told the commission that some of the
800 public submissions received so far have
been harrowing, and that the commission is
grateful for the bravery of those people.
He told those in attendance that
allegations against specific providers or
individuals are for another time.
Providers slow to respond
From Gray’s opening, we also learnt that
the Department of Health has forwarded
any submissions it received when the
commission was first announced – with
some previously concerned that these may
be lost or not considered.
We also heard that, as of now, only 900
of the 2000 registered providers, and only
79 of the top 100, have responded to the
commission with details of any instances
of substandard care – a fact that will not be
looked kindly upon by the commissioners.
“We will follow up the providers who have
not responded to the request to ensure it
has been received and has been receiving
proper attention,” Gray said.
“As commissioner Briggs noted previously,
providers who do not engage with our
requests draw attention to themselves and
to their practices. They will be subject to
careful scrutiny.”
Spriggs was eventually called to testify
jointly with her son Clive. She used her time
not to dwell on her family’s story, she told
the commission, but to encourage others to
come forward.
COTA Australia chief executive Ian Yates
spoke for most of the remainder of
the day, covering topics ranging from
overmedication, the difficulties regulators
face catching misdeeds in facilities, to aged
care funding and future improvements.
In his witness statement, Yates told Gray
that when it comes to funding aged care
properly, “we don’t really know whether …
the total amount that providers are receiving
is adequate”.
“And, in that context, what proportion
should be paid for by the government, the
taxpayer, which is, in the end, a subsidy
to our care and in many cases to our
accommodation, and what should be paid
by individuals who have capacity to pay.
And, at the moment, we do not have a
coherent policy about that”.
Using the Home Care Packages system
Levels 1–4 as an example, Yates said that
the financial means testing does not
even out across the country, telling the
commission that we need a fairer system
that is plain and easy for everyone to
understand and would pass “the pub test”.
In his written statement, Yates said:
“Improving respect for older Australians
will be a critical part of any future aged
care system.”
He also suggested a single national plan
for older Australians, which would put in
place strategies to eliminate ageism, as key
to future safety in the sector.
Setting the scene
At the end of the first day’s hearing, Clive
Spriggs told Nursing Review how important
it was for him and his mother “to be the
first to present and speak, and ... to be able
to speak in front of the royal commission
and get our point across to them and set
the scene for what’s going to happen and
where things are going to go”.
Asked whether they thought this was
finally the time that change would occur,
Barbara Spriggs was confident.