news
Scrutiny on vax objectors
Philosopher argues that conscientious objectors to
vaccination need to give back to society in other ways.
C
onscientious objectors to
immunisation should make a
commensurate contribution
to society to account for the risk their
decision imposes on the community, an
Australian philosopher has argued.
Associate professor Steve Clarke,
from Charles Sturt University’s School
of Humanities and Social Sciences,
co-authored the paper Conscientious
Objection to Vaccination , published online
in Bioethics, which explored whether
people should be entitled to object, and
if so, what constraints or requirements
should be placed on the decision.
Clarke and his co-authors said there was a
case for conscientious objectors to make an
appropriate contribution to society.
“Objectors could make a financial
contribution to the state that reflects the
degree of risk imposed on the community,
either via a penalty or lack of access to a
benefit,” he said.
Clarke said the federal government’s
D
Breast not best
for mobiles
Research reveals worrying extent
of women carrying mobile
phones against their skin.
4 | nursingreview.com.au
No Jab, No Pay policy, which involves
withholding benefits to conscientious
objectors who refuse to have their children
vaccinated, was consistent with this approach.
The authors of the paper also suggested
that the contribution would depend on
the severity of the relevant disease, its
morbidity and the likelihood that vaccine
refusal would lead to harm.
“In particular, the contribution required
will depend on whether the rate of
conscientious objection in a given
population threatens herd immunity to the
disease in question,” the paper read.
The paper also argued that people
conscientiously objecting to vaccination
should supply evidence of their sincerity.
“Current practices don’t generally
require Australians to state the reasons
for their objection,” Clarke said. “They just
have to fill out a form and have it signed
by a practitioner to certify a healthcare
professional has discussed the benefits of
immunisation with them.”
He added that a contribution to society
may also function as a demonstration of
sincerity. ■
espite manufacturers’ warnings, some women still
carry their smartphone in their bra.
This issue was the focus of a Monash University study,
published in PLOS One, that surveyed 197 Melbourne-based
women aged 15–40 to find out where and how near to the body
smartphones were carried and used.
While the results showed the most common location of
smartphones – when not in use or when being used for
purposes other than calls – was off the body, the next most
common was in the hand (58 per cent), in a pocket below the
waist (57 per cent), or against the breast (15 per cent).
A quarter of the women surveyed also indicated they had at
some stage carried their phone against their breast.
Dr Mary Redmayne, adjunct research fellow with
Monash University’s School of Public Health and Preventive
Medicine, said people were exposed to considerably higher
levels of radiofrequency electromagnetic radiation by
storing their smartphones next to their skin rather than in a
bag or on a nearby surface.
Redmayne warned that modern smartphones were equipped
with applications that updated automatically in the background
and that this generated electromagnetic radiation in addition to
the regular signal contact with the nearest base station.
The study revealed many participants understood the potential
dangers of carrying a smartphone against their skin, with only 5
per cent of survey respondents indicating they were unaware that
smartphones emitted electromagnetic energy.
Participants also spoke of their concerns about cancer,
sleep issues and headaches or dizziness. However, these
concerns did not stop them from storing their phones in a
pocket or near the breast during the day. ■