workforce
Nazi Germany is not relevant today, but this exemplar of nurses
being involved in executions is a perfect example of why it is still
very relevant to learn this history.
The paper you’ve just published has the views of 12 senior
nurses in Australia, the US and the UK. Can you provide more
detail about what those nurses said?
“
She also argued that
if she hadn’t put the
intravenous lines in, they
would use unqualified
people to do so, and the
prisoner would suffer
more.
they would hurt the patient. They also said that it was better for
them to do it because the patient knew and trusted them and they
could provide good care up until the patient died. Now, to me, the
rationale given by the nurse who killed the prisoners in executions
a few years ago was very similar to the rationale given by those
nurses in Nazi Germany who killed their patients.
My reason for studying this and bringing it to attention today is
that we must learn from history. Nurses who are going to work in
areas where ethical dilemmas abound; for example, in euthanasia,
as euthanasia laws are becoming debated so strongly in Australia;
[and] in prenatal screening, where fetuses are terminated before
they … are born if they have a disability or an abnormality. I’m not
saying these things are right or wrong, but what I am saying is
nurses and midwives who come across these ethical dilemmas,
and who might work in areas where these are being carried out,
should know the history so that they can make informed decisions
about whether or not they want to work in those areas.
You spoke about four distinct types of dilemma in that
description: pre-birth terminations, legal executions,
euthanasia and programs of orchestrated homicide during
Nazi Germany. Looking at those four issues, would you classify
yourself as a moral relativist or a moral absolutist when
discussing what nurses should and shouldn’t do?
I would have to go down a moral relativist line. I think that each
situation should be judged individually, but I think nurses who
are going to work in these areas – if they know the history, if
they know what’s gone before and the end result of that history
– can make better informed decisions about what they want to
do themselves, and that’s why I think this is very important. I’ve
had people tell me that nurses would not do these things and, of
course, we know that’s patently untrue. I’ve had people tell me
that the work I’m doing on the history of nurses and midwives in
The 12 of us were either very senior academics or senior people
working in clinical areas. [We had] directors of nursing, [and] we
had many professors. Many of the nurses are researchers or study
ethics, some don’t. Some of them agreed that the comments
made by the nurse in the radio interview in America that I cited,
they agreed with her. They said that yes, if someone is going to
die, it is a moral duty of a nurse to provide the best care possible
for that person until they die, regardless of how they’re dying.
Others disagree. Others said that no, nurses should never be
involved in execution or torture of any kind. So it was a certainly a
divergence of opinions on what should happen.
Some of us, including me, cite the International Council of
Nurses code of conduct that says nurses should never, under any
circumstance, be involved in these things.
We must remember that these were the personal opinions of all
these 12 people. But others called for a debate around the code of
conduct to consider what is happening in reality and to consider
whether the code of conduct should be reviewed to take account
of these circumstances that are happening and the nurses’
involvement in things like executions.
On the flip side, say there’d been a particularly heinous
crime like a massacre and the accused perpetrator has been
injured and has been taken to the hospital requiring medical
attention. Do you feel that nurses have an obligation to treat
the person who has committed the crime given that they’ve
killed several people, or do they have a right to refuse to
provide medical care?
I personally believe that they must provide the care to people
regardless of who they are and what they did. Had it been my child
who the person killed, I may well change my mind. That probably
makes me the moral relativist you mentioned before.
The nurses who wrote the paper, would probably agree with
me saying that. The difference is that when you have someone
brought in for care who has done something terrible, they are still
there for you to care for. If you have a prisoner in prison awaiting
execution who’s going to be killed by the state deliberately, then
that puts a very different perspective on it.
Everybody who wrote that paper disagreed with capital
punishment, but they took the view that regardless of who the
patient is, what the circumstances are, they must give the best
care possible.
I would agree with that but I would not agree with nurses
being actively involved in the killing of that patient, and that’s the
difference. If they had done some horrible murder and they come
into you and you have to care for them, then you give the best
care you can – but you cannot cross that line and actively kill
them or be involved in their killing actively. That’s the moral full
stop for me. And the people who read the paper would agree with
that. They would say that the nurse c an’t give the lethal injection
itself, but they do believe that the nurse should give care to the
patient who’s going to get that lethal injection. My argument is that
by being [involved by] cleaning the IV line so the injection can be
given, you’ve crossed that line. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 27