INDUSTRY & REFORM
example – we probably wouldn’t feel too reluctant to speak up and
say to someone, “Oh, this isn’t quite right,” or, “We didn’t order this
dish,” or whatever it may be.
But what we found in our research is that in a healthcare setting,
which is still a service, which sometimes people pay for either
directly or through insurance, or some other way, people feel
reluctant to speak up. So even if they feel like something is going
wrong, even if they have a concern, often people have a reluctance
to speak up against their doctors, and that’s what we call hostage
bargaining syndrome. So patients begin to act like hostages to
the healthcare system, and there is a perceived power imbalance
between the doctor and the patient – because patients often put
doctors on a pedestal. They think, “This person has many, many
years of expertise and training. Who am I to question what they’re
telling me, or the treatment plan they’re laying out for me?”
And often even very educated people, even people that perhaps
have a medical background, experience hostage bargaining
syndrome, where they’re effectively silenced and lose their voice,
and don’t feel comfortable speaking up and questioning, or raising
concerns, or criticising what’s happening with their own care.
What are some examples that study participants described?
One that stays in my mind is a young mother who was at hospital
with her child who was receiving chemotherapy, and she noticed her
child’s voice had changed. It was a small child, only about 18 months
old. The cry of this young child had changed and this concerned her,
so she raised it with her nurses and doctors, and they did a number
of tests but couldn’t find anything.
Over the next few days this continued – she felt like there was
something wrong, like the cry was changing, and she became
increasingly anxious about it. She raised it one or two more times.
Once again the doctors checked the child over and couldn’t find
anything, and then she started to feel like she was becoming a
problematic mother, that maybe they were looking at her as if
she was an overanxious mother. So although she was getting
increasingly anxious about her child, she stopped voicing that
anxiety. She didn’t want to take up the doctor’s time – the consultant
was busy, and she didn’t want to be seen as the overanxious parent,
the one who always has problems or questions when the doctors
come into the room.
And in fact, later on, there was a problem detected, and it was the
problem she had identified right at the beginning. It just took a long
time to manifest. And then she felt really bad because she didn’t
speak up and wasn’t more forceful. She felt guilty that a medical
situation had arisen with her child and she didn’t push hard enough
because of hostage bargaining syndrome, essentially. She felt that
her child suffered needlessly because she didn’t feel comfortable
speaking up in that situation.
What are some examples of the types of nurse or doctor
behaviour that might be contributing to the issue?
We spoke to a lot of clinicians, and they equally don’t want the
hostage bargaining syndrome. The medical profession understands
that shared decision-making is really important, that patients and
doctors are able to work together, work through concerns, set a
treatment plan that is not only medically sound but also meets the
needs of the patient or family involved.
Quite a few of the doctors would say things like, “If you have
questions, please raise them.” But what we found was those sorts of
statements didn’t go far enough to alleviate the hostage bargaining
syndrome. So a lot of it, from the clinician’s point of view, is simply
sitting down with the patient, making eye contact, not seeming like
you have to rush out of the room, not seeming like you’re in a hurry
to move on to the next task, taking the time to talk to the patient. Get
to know the patient, build that trust, because you need that level of
trust between the doctor and patient before you can start breaking
down the hostage bargaining syndrome, and before you can move
towards shared decision-making.
How might staff spot a patient who might be having difficulty
in voicing their concerns?
There are subtle cues and also more overt markers. People who
come from a lower socioeconomic standard, who have lower
education levels, experience hostage bargaining syndrome
more severely than more educated, more confident patients. So
straightaway you have a patient group that, through no fault of their
own – just because of perhaps their education levels or the amount
of time they’ve spent in the medical system – are very affected by
hostage bargaining syndrome.
But in general, for patients who are normally quite confident, it
would manifest by simply not engaging in conversation, not asking
questions. You might think to yourself, “Oh, we’re talking about this
treatment plan, it’s quite complicated, and the patient doesn’t have
any questions of me? They don’t seem to be engaging.”
Or perhaps they seem like they have a piece of paper where
they’ve written down some questions, but they’re not asking
those questions. Those sort of things might infer that the patient is
struggling with hostage bargaining syndrome.
At its most extreme, we found that hostage bargaining syndrome
leads to what’s called learned helplessness. And that’s essentially
where the patient gives up. They feel like nothing they say or do is
going to change the circumstance, so they become disengaged
with the whole process, and therefore the ability to get them to be
involved in shared decision-making about their own care becomes
incredibly challenging for the doctors and nurses.
How can patients best be supported to assert themselves?
The big element here is this concept of shared decision-making, and
underlying that is the idea of trust and commitment. So a patient
needs to feel like t hey trust their doctor. Unfortunately, trust is
something that often needs to be built up over multiple interactions.
Some of the best examples we saw of clinicians doing things that
break down the hostage bargaining syndrome is simply where, when
they had to discuss, for example, a treatment plan with a patient,
they would bring them into a quiet office. They would close the
door, put their phone or pager to the side, and sit down with the
patient to show they had the time to spend with them. Also, they
encouraged follow-up questions, and if the patient seemed reluctant
to ask specific questions, they tried to draw them out.
Sometimes patients feel like if they question – and particularly if
they criticise – the health system or care team, that they’re going to
jeopardise a really important relationship.
The mother I spoke about earlier said she felt she was jeopardising
an important relationship by questioning the care team, and to
her, these are the people who will save the life of her child. So
that’s when she feels very much like a hostage: “I’m bargaining for
my child’s life, and I have these concerns, but I’m worried about
jeopardising that relationship. I’m worried about jeopardising the
care my child is going to get by questioning or being critical of
my care team.”
And whether that’s real or perceived doesn’t matter. If that person
feels that way, it stops them from speaking up when they should. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 11