news
Questionable body of work
Real Bodies exhibition
reveals gaps in fight against
human organ trafficking.
By Dallas Bastian
A
controversial exhibition featuring
plastinated human cadavers,
organs, embryos and fetuses
is “illustrative of an apparent gap in the
current legislation”, a parliamentary
inquiry says.
Details of the exhibition were included
as a case study in the inquiry’s final
report, Compassion, Not Commerce: An
Inquiry into Human Organ Trafficking and
Organ Transplant Tourism.
MP David Shoebridge told the sub-
committee investigating human organ
trafficking: “The proprietors … have been
asked about the circumstances in which
these bodies came into their possession,
and they have been unable and unwilling
to prove that any of the persons on
display ever gave their consent.”
The report also held that Thomas Zaller,
president of exhibition organiser Imagine
Exhibitions, stated the human bodies and
tissue were sourced from China and were
unclaimed by relatives of the deceased.
“Mr Zaller has indicated that the
cadavers were sourced from Dr Hong-Jin
Sui of Dalian Medical University in China
between 2000 and 2004,” the report said.
6 | nursingreview.com.au
In a statement to News Corp, Dr
Sui said the cadavers were “originally
received from the city morgue and then
transferred to medical universities in
China” and that they “have been legally
donated [and] certified to have died of
natural causes”.
According to an investigative report
by German weekly news magazine
Der Spiegel, a number of human cadavers
sourced from Dr Sui between 2000 and
2004 were later observed to have bullet
holes in their skulls.
The same report also claims that
in email correspondence dated
29 December 2001, Dr Sui described
two specific cadavers he had obtained
as “very fresh”, having been shot that day
and had their livers removed, allegedly for
transplantation.
The Compassion, Not Commerce report
recommended that to protect the human
rights of deceased persons and their
families, only organs or human tissue that
have the proper documentation recording
donor consent should be approved for
importation into Australia.
The report made 12 recommendations
for combatting human organ trafficking
and organ transplant tourism.
Among them were that the Australian
government strengthen the nation’s
involvement in international efforts to
combat human organ trafficking and
“thoroughly investigate reforms that
would enhance Australia’s domestic
organ donation program”.
While most Australians are willing to
donate their organs, only one in three
are registered as donors.
Kevin Andrews, chair of the Human
Rights Sub-Committee of the Joint
Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs,
Defence and Trade, said the demand for
donor organs continues to outstrip supply
– around 1400 Australians are on the
waiting list for a transplant.
This gap has enabled an illicit
commercial market of organ trafficking
and transplant tourism to flourish in
some overseas destinations, he said.
“This practice gives hope to the
desperate but comes with serious
medical risk, both for the donor and the
organ reciprocates, and often exploits
the poorest and most vulnerable in
communities.”
The report also recommended the
government improve relevant data
collection, support public health
education programs, and strengthen
Australia’s legal prohibitions on organ
trafficking.
“Compassion, not commerce, is
the key,” Andrews said in the report’s
foreword. ■