news
Commissioners Richard
Tracey and Lynelle Briggs.
Photo: Kelly Barnes, AAP
Royal commission begins
Day one kicks off with
drama in Adelaide.
By Conor Burke
T
he hallmark of a civilised society
is how it treats its most vulnerable
people – and our elderly are often
among our most physically, emotionally and
financially vulnerable.”
These were some of the final words
from commissioner Richard Tracey on the
first day of the keenly anticipated Royal
Commission into Aged Care Quality and
Safety in Adelaide, with those gathered
given a glimpse into what to expect over
the next year.
Although proceedings were somewhat
marred for some of the families and
campaigners for the elderly – including
Clive Spriggs, son of Oakden whistleblower
Barb Spriggs – who were unceremoniously
deposited in the outer spill rooms in favour
of lawyers and heads of peak bodies.
Prominent aged care advocate in
attendance Stewart Johnston told Nursing
Review that he and others, including
Spriggs, were originally ushered to the
front of the queue to enter the hearing by
a security guard.
“We’re standing there, and this woman
appears and says, ‘You need to get to the
back’,” he said.
“They said, ‘You need to get to the back.
You’re not important ... I’ve spoken to the
commissioners, and these people have
been here first’. We were dumbfounded.”
The opening of the hearing itself had
less drama. Dr James Popple, the official
secretary, set the tone of the proceedings
by recognising the contribution of elder
4 | nursingreview.com.au
Australians to our nation and the need for
the commission to uphold their dignity.
He reminded those gathered that as
our population is ageing, the community
expects government to have the best
policy and frameworks possible.
Tracey started by reaffirming the
commission’s “broad remit” which includes
investigating young people with disabilities
in the aged care system, those with
dementia and the overarching need to
examine “sub-standard care and systemic
failures” within the system.
He also pointed to the commission’s
interest in the newly formed Aged Care
Quality and Safety Commission and said
the royal commission will follow “the
new regime to form a judgment about
its efficacy”.
In her address, commissioner Lynelle
Briggs said it is extremely important to
investigate current policy and practice in
the sector in answer to the “rising torrent
of concern that the system is faltering” and
to “ensure all Australians have confidence
that the system will serve them” when the
time comes.
Briggs conceded the commission has
only a short time in which to conduct
its inquiry but stressed it will consult
extensively with experts, researchers,
government stakeholders, the public and
those affected by failures of the system.
“We will give voice to them,” she said.
Addressing concerns of privacy and
whistleblowing, Tracey made clear that
although at this point the commission
is only asking for submissions, it will, if
needed, compel witnesses. He added that
any confidentiality clauses in contracts
of current or former employees will not
exclude people from summons and
that the commission would be “gravely
concerned” if any provider or government
told staff not to talk to the commission.
Furthermore, he stated the commission
will afford protections to any whistleblowers
and outlined penalties should any
repercussions be felt by those who testify.
Assisting councils Peter Gray and
Dr Timothy McEvoy laid out some of the
finer details of the hearings to come,
as well as observations of submissions
received at this time.
So far, 83 providers have responded,
covering 2000 outlets. The tenor of
responses include instances of elder abuse,
medicine mismanagement, misuse of
psychotropics, food safety, poor wound care
leading to death and poor record keeping.
Campaigner Johnston was, on the
whole, pleased with the opening hearing.
Although he did have some concern for
the “5000 submissions received before the
portal was up” apparently going instead to
the Department of Health.
“Somebody needs to be questioning
those, because anyone who would be able
to knock out a significant submission straight
away would be the ones that are giving the
really good information,” Johnston said.
“And how did they send it to the
Department of Health? That concerns me.”
Johnston also stressed the need for the
roundtables and community engagement
to happened as soon as possible, as
he believes consulting with the current
providers and peak bodies is not enough.
“I do hope they consult with people with
lived experience,” he said.
“LASA and all of that are in there talking
to the commissioners on their own before
the public are allowed into the hearing
today. That’s the problem – there is a lack
of trust from the community.”
As for the immediate future, the
first substantive hearing is slated for
11–18 February. It will be an overview of
the current system of operations and will
also hear witness testimony from those
receiving care.
Yet to be announced are the dates
for any roundtables and community
consultations, but all of those involved
were at pains to stress that these are to
be held in all of the major cities as well as
regional areas where possible.
The commission’s interim report will
be released on 31 October this year, with
30 April 2020 as the deadline for a final
report and recommendations. ■