news
Nurses
behaving
badly
Profanity, demeaning patients,
product promotion – how nurses
are ‘misbehaving’ on Twitter.
By Dallas Bastian
S
ocial media is a great way to network and advocate for
change. It’s also a great way to get in trouble.
Nurses hear both of these pieces of advice in near
equal measure.
Indeed, international researchers, led by Associate Professor
Jennie De Gagne from Duke University in the US, said that while
social media can be a resource for nurses – allowing them to
share health information and keep up with medical developments
– when used inappropriately, it can degrade the working and
learning environment, harm reputations and negatively affect
patient safety.
To find out what this inappropriate social media use looks like,
the US and South Korean research team looked at the Twitter
posts of nurses and nursing students to screen for ‘cyberincivility’
– the use of disrespectful, insensitive or disruptive behaviour in
an electronic environment that interferes with another person’s
personal, professional or social wellbeing.
Of the 163 Twitter users included in the study, the team found
over a third (36.8 per cent) tweeted inappropriately at least once
and, on average, made six uncivil posts over a six-week period.
Overall, 413 tweets were deemed uncivil. Of those, 240 related
to the nursing profession, and the rest to personal life.
So what exactly were the kinds of uncivil tweets nurses were
sending out?
Profanity was the most common offence. The researchers
wrote: “Profane texts focused on users’ work environments and
included obscenities aimed at patients and co-workers.
“Some of the work-related tweets in this category included
quotes from patients about genitalia, threats of sexual violence,
and descriptions of assaults.”
Product promotion, sexually explicit or suggestive posts, and
demeaning remarks about patients were next in line, while tweets
2 | nursingreview.com.au
involving name-calling, rude comments and interprofessional
aggression were also sent out, though in lower numbers.
Perhaps fitting into a few of those categories, nurses used social
media to call people names like “bitch”, “liar”, “idiot”, “complete
c**k”, “fat virgin” and “f***ing savage”.
The authors wrote that: “Of the 240 tweets related to nursing,
there were 29 instances (12.1 per cent) of nurses demeaning
patients, which included tweets that suggested tricking a patient
by giving a fake name, inappropriately venting about a patient’s
condition, making jokes about a patient’s situation, or otherwise
tweeting unprofessionally about a patient.
“This category also included the use of memes and GIFs, which
were used to depict patient behaviours and often portrayed them
negatively. For example, one GIF showed a head shaking to display
disgust, while another exhibited eye-rolling to imply the patient
was acting inappropriately.”
Last year, a nurse at Texas Children’s Hospital was let go after
she posted information about a boy who tested positive for
measles on an anti-vaccination Facebook group.
Following the incident, the hospital said in a statement: “We
were made aware that one of our nurses posted protected health
information regarding a patient on social media.
“We take these matters very seriously, as the privacy and
wellbeing of our patients is always a top priority. After an internal
investigation, this individual is no longer with the organisation.”
But should nurses be held responsible for their posts if they
don’t breach codes of conduct or organisation guidelines?
A survey of medical students, pointed to in the study, revealed
that 42 per cent believed their online activity did not have any
bearing on who they were as professionals. Respondents also
voiced their frustration with the “unrealistic expectations that
institutions had about their online behaviour and that institutional
restrictions excluded normal social interaction”.
Nevertheless, the authors suggested nurse leaders review
their organisation’s social media policies and weigh up their
effectiveness in terms of protecting the integrity of the profession
and patient privacy. They also said educators should ensure
students understand that they will be held accountable for their
social media presence. ■