Nursing Review Issue 06 Nov-Dec 2020 | Page 9

news
news

Fault line

What does vaccine indemnity mean for Australians ?

The Australian government has given

the suppliers of two COVID-19 vaccines indemnity against liability for rare side-effects – but one academic argues Australia needs compensation schemes in place .
Associate Professor Nicholas Wood , from the Faculty of Medicine and Health at the University of Sydney , said while details are scant , it appears the government would “ foot the bill for compensation ” should a member of the public win legal action against the drug companies behind the University of Oxford or University of Queensland vaccine .
Writing for The Conversation , Wood said while such a deal is not entirely unheard of or unexpected – with the government previously providing some indemnity to companies that make vaccines against smallpox and influenza – it is “ not ideal ” for a member of the public who believes they have been injured by a vaccine .
“ The person still has to engage with the legal system , which is both costly and complex , and there ’ s no guarantee of success ,” he said .
“ Compensation may not even be possible via our legal system . That ’ s because in most cases , it will be difficult to show in court a serious side-effect was due to a fault in the vaccine composition or negligence in the way it was administered .
“ So in Australia , people with a vaccine injury , either COVID-19 or other vaccine , will likely bear the costs of their injury by themselves , and seek treatment by our publicly-funded or private health systems .” Australia is not alone in its approach to indemnity deals for COVID-19 vaccines
– governments in the UK , US and the European Union have also agreed to indemnify manufacturers .
However , 25 countries , including Japan , the US , the UK , Germany and New Zealand , have in place no-fault compensation schemes for rare vaccine side-effects .
Wood said there are numerous benefits to a no-fault vaccine compensation system . “ These include simplified access to compensation , and avoiding a lengthy , costly and complex encounter with the legal system , with no guarantee of success .”
Still , he added , compensation awarded via such a scheme is usually lower than what a person would receive after a successful liability lawsuit .
Wood said if the government wants to encourage people to get a COVID-19 jab when one is available , Australia needs compensation schemes in place .
“ Although it is important manufacturers receive indemnity for ‘ certain liabilities ’, we still need to look after our community . That means a compensation system the public can easily access and which provides appropriate support .” ■
Labor leader Anthony Albanese . Photo : Bianca De Marchi

Under control

Albanese promises centre for disease control .
By Dallas Bastian and AAP

A

Labor government would set up a centre for disease control to strengthen Australia ’ s preparedness for future pandemics , party leader Anthony Albanese says . Albanese said lives and the economy depended on Australia getting its response to future pandemics right .
“ Ask any Australian and they ’ ll tell you our response to the coronavirus pandemic was too slow , too reactive and too uncoordinated ,” he said . “ We can ’ t be left playing catch-up again .”
The centre for disease control ( CDC ) would house surveillance experts and systems to monitor current and emerging threats and work with state and territory governments and service providers to improve preparedness in the health and aged care sectors .
It would also manage the National Medical Stockpile and run regular preparedness drills .
Establishing a CDC has support from the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation , the Australian Medical Association and Public Health Association of Australia .
The Australian Healthcare and Hospitals Association also backed the move , with CEO Alison Verhoeven saying : “ The call for this has been long-standing , with a 2013 recommendation to the Government by the Standing Committee on Health and Ageing overlooked in favour of the development of a National Communicable Disease Framework .
“ Inconsistent messaging and conflicting expert advice across jurisdictions was partly addressed ‘ on the run ’ by the establishment of the National Cabinet , with the Australian Health Protection Principal Committee reporting directly to it .
“ However , this has resulted in a reduction in public transparency about disease control decision-making processes .
“ A Centre for Disease Control requires a level of independence from political decision-making , with accountability and transparency identified in the enabling legislation .”
Labor argued Australia was the only OECD country without such a centre .
Labor ’ s health spokesperson Chris Bowen said 90 per cent of Australian deaths were associated with chronic illness , with 38 per cent of the disease burden preventable .
“ Health experts have been calling for an Australian CDC for more than three decades .
“ It ’ s time to get on with it .” ■ nursingreview . com . au | 7