Nursing Review Issue 05 Sep-Oct 2020 | Page 12

industry & reform
industry & reform

Shining a light

COVID-19 has revealed ‘ human rights abuses ’ that pregnant women face .
By Conor Burke

Pregnant women have faced

significant obstacles over the last eight months . On top of the challenges expectant mothers usually experience they have the added stress of a once-in-a-generation pandemic . Add to the mix a consistent stream of inconsistencies nationwide over hospital birthing protocols , and what should be a wonderful experience for most women has become considerably less so .
Women have had very specific birth plans changed and changed back again by government and hospital policy , and many women feel they are being denied the choice to birth the way they want . Health experts also worry how this will affect the health and wellbeing of children born of the pandemic .
10 | nursingreview . com . au
For Melbourne woman Sarah Sherman , pregnant with her second child , it started when she was looking for a new hospital .
“ When I went to my first appointment with them , I got to the hospital and the reception staff literally treated me like I ’ d walked in there with a bomb . They were like , ‘ Why are you here ?’ They were really rude to me ,” she told Nursing Review .
At her next appointment she was told to wait in the carpark , phone the midwife and conduct a thirty-minute interview over the phone before she was allowed to set foot in the hospital for her tests .
Sherman feels that the level of care she has received compared to her first pregnancy is “ non-existent ” and that this pregnancy has been “ stressful ” and a “ joyless experience ” as she battles constant worries over whether her hospital will allow her to have a water birth or even gas and air .
NO RIGHTS Professor Hannah Dahlen from Western Sydney University says this is a symptom of the constant infringements on the rights of pregnant women , now brought to light by the pandemic .
Dahlen uses the recent stoush over showers and water births as a case in point . The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists ( RANZCOG ) has come out against the use of water in the birth setting . “ What RANZCOG put out a couple of weeks ago was , I think , giving open slather to deep biases and agendas . Obstetricians have never liked water birth . To be honest , hospital managers are highly suspicious of water birth . Many people find it quite peculiar and only because women insist on doing it do we provide them the support for it , not only because the evidence tells us that actually it ’ s a very safe thing to do and women really like it and it helps ,” Dahlen tells Nursing Review .
The RANZCOG website says : “ However , in the setting of increased community transmission of coronavirus ( COVID-19 ), services are advised to suspend the use of water immersion for labour and birth for all women . The protection of our maternity