clinical practice
Up in the air
Australian scientist says WHO is
ignoring COVID-19 aerosol risk.
By AAP
Six months into a pandemic that has
killed more than half a million people,
more than 200 scientists from around
the world are challenging the official view of
how the coronavirus spreads.
The World Health Organization and
the US Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention maintain that you have to worry
about only two types of transmission:
inhaling respiratory droplets from an
infected person in your immediate vicinity
or, less common, touching a contaminated
surface and then your eyes, nose or mouth.
But other experts contend that the
guidance ignores growing evidence that a
third pathway also plays a significant role in
contagion.
They say multiple studies demonstrate
that particles known as aerosols –
microscopic versions of standard
respiratory droplets – can hang in the
air for long periods and float for several
metres, making poorly ventilated rooms,
buses and other confined spaces
dangerous even when people stay
1.8 metres from one another.
“We are 100 per cent sure about this,”
said Lidia Morawska, a professor of
atmospheric sciences and environmental
engineering at Queensland University of
Technology.
She made the case in an open letter
to the WHO accusing the United Nations
agency of failing to issue appropriate
warnings about the risk.
A total of 239 researchers from 32
countries signed the letter, which is set to
be published in a scientific journal.
In interviews, experts said that
aerosol transmission appears to be
the only way to explain several “superspreading”
events, including the
infection of diners at a restaurant in
China who sat at separate tables and
of choir members in the US state of
Washington who took precautions during
a rehearsal.
WHO officials have acknowledged
that the virus can be transmitted through
aerosols but say that occurs only during
medical procedures such as intubation
that can spew large quantities of the
microscopic particles.
Dr Benedetta Allegranzi, a top WHO
expert on infection prevention and control,
said in response to questions from the
Los Angeles Times that Morawska and
her group presented theories based
on laboratory experiments rather than
evidence from the field.
“We value and respect their opinions and
contributions to this debate,” Allegranzi
wrote in an email.
But in weekly teleconferences, a large
majority of a group of more than 30
international experts advising the WHO
has “not judged the existing evidence
sufficiently convincing to consider airborne
transmission as having an important role in
COVID-19 spread”.
She added that such transmission “would
have resulted in many more cases and even
more rapid spread of the virus”.
The proponents of aerosol transmission
said masks worn correctly would help
prevent the escape of exhaled aerosols
as well as inhalation of the microscopic
particles.
“We think the virus has
been transmitted this way all
along"
But they said the spread could also be
reduced by improving ventilation and
zapping indoor air with ultraviolet light in
ceiling units.
Jose Jimenez, a University of Colorado
chemist who signed the letter, said the idea
of aerosol transmission should not frighten
people.
“It’s not like the virus has changed,”
he said.
“We think the virus has been transmitted
this way all along, and knowing about it
helps protect us.” ■
nursingreview.com.au | 21