industry & reform
• At 2.21pm A sent a reply email to the clinic requesting that
future communications for him be sent to an alternate
personal email address.
• At 2.34pm the clinic sent an email to A’s personal email address
and copied the incorrect email address concerning B. That email
attached a consent form for the medical study.
• At 5.34pm A sent a reply email to the clinic notifying them that it
had used the incorrect email address concerning B.
Check twice, click once
The legal implications of
incorrectly sending patient
information via email.
By Scott Trueman
Nurses are required to maintain patient confidentially due to
their legal, moral, ethical, employment and professional
duties as they are trusted with a patient’s most intimate
and personal information.
This trust is often a challenge to maintain when working in busy
clinical environments. For example, emailing sensitive medical
information is fraught with dangers, including the difficulty of
retrieving it if sent to the wrong recipient.
Most nurses and health services are governed by the
Commonwealth Privacy Act (1988). Pursuant to the Act there
are a number of mandatory Australian Privacy Principles (APP)
which need to be adhered to. When a nurse or health service
breaches these APPs there are potential serious consequences,
including investigation, prosecution and payment of monetary
damages. This jurisdiction is governed by the Information
Commissioner (OAIC).
In a recent case, two patients’ grievances related to a health
clinic’s disclosure of their personal medical information twice
to an unknown recipient by using an incorrect Gmail address.
Both patients were diagnosed as HIV positive. Patient A and
his husband (Patient B) had previously been part of research
facilitated by the clinic concerning HIV transmission. They
had both previously provided their respective email addresses.
Relevantly, A provided his work email address, which included
a reference to his place of employment, and B provided a
personal email address which was comprised of his first and last
name, as well as his middle initial.
Summarily the facts as set out are:
• At 2.19pm on 22 December 2017 the clinic sent an email to
A’s work email address, and to an incorrect email address
containing B’s first and last name but omitting his middle initial.
With no response from the clinic, A sent an email on 25 January
2018 to the clinic advising he would be making a complaint to the
Information Commissioner. On 29 January the clinic emailed A a
letter (dated 26 January 2018) apologising for the ‘inconvenience and
disappointment’ caused, setting out the steps it had taken in response
to the incident, and stating that it was undertaking an investigation.
A and B lodged a complaint with the OAIC on 14 February 2018.
In the formal complaint A claimed that the clinic interfered with
his privacy because:
• It disclosed his and B’s personal and sensitive information
without their consent to an unknown third party.
• The information included: A’s name, work/employer, partner’s
(B) name, that he was part of a sensitive research study, recent
diagnosis of HIV and B’s existing HIV positive condition.
• They understood their personal information would not be
shared with anyone and stored securely.
Pursuant to the APP this is deemed ‘sensitive information’
requiring additional caution in distributing.
The health service submitted that it did undertake steps to
address the error, including:
• Sending a follow-up email to the incorrect email address and
requesting that the email be deleted or shredded – with no
response.
• Engaging with Google to attempt to have the email destroyed.
• Offering to reimburse A for costs incurred through
counselling sessions.
• Making a written apology to A.
• Undertaking a number of steps to protect client personal
information in the future.
The Information Commissioner found that (A and B’s)
‘personal (‘sensitive’) information’ had been disclosed as defined
in the Privacy Act, including both A and B’s sexual orientation.
Accordingly, the clinic was in breach of APP 11.1.
Both A and B claimed that the disclosures caused them
significant personal distress and psychological injury (including
cost of treatment). The Information Commissioner ordered the
health service to issue a formal letter of apology, instructed it to
undertake specific steps to ensure the breach was not repeated
and awarded $10,000 in compensation to A and $3,000 to B.
The lessons for nurses arising from this case reinforce the
requirement that if in managerial positions they must ensure
their workplace has policies, procedures and training for the
safe storage (digital or otherwise) of medical information and its
dissemination, whether electronically or otherwise.
Nurses as employees have a duty to the patient, profession and
employers to ensure they act in such matters with all reasonable
skill and diligence to maintain a patient’s privacy. ■
Scott Trueman is a lecturer in the School of Nursing, Midwifery
and Nutrition at James Cook University.
10 | nursingreview.com.au