workforce
No show
What would happen if nurses
stopped showing up for work?
By Conor Burke
What happens if this pandemic
gets worse? What if it got so
bad that healthcare workers,
doctors and nurses all walked off the job?
While the Australian healthcare system
has been stretched by the COVID-19
crisis, it has yet to feel its full force
when compared to its US or European
counterparts.
We have seen coronavirus cases explode
in the US, and a number of doctors and
nurses have criticised the lack of essential
PPE available to protect themselves,
resulting in a number of health workers
falling ill and dying.
In early March when the first Australian
aged care home experienced an outbreak
of COVID-19, aged care workers refused to
come to work the following day.
After news of the outbreak was
confirmed by BaptistCare, The Australian
reported that aged care staff collectively
called in sick, forcing the NSW Health
Department to step in.
“NSW Health has had to agree to fund
NSW Health staff into a nursing home that
has had some coronavirus issues and its
staff have become, for whatever reason,
unavailable,” said NSW Health Minister
Brad Hazzard at the time.
Staff who did go to work at the facility
said they were not given any information
about what was happening.
If PPE becomes scarce and the rates of
infection go up, would nurses be forced to
choose between the safety of patients and
the safety of their family and themselves?
Erin Smith, associate professor in
disaster and emergency response within
the School of Medical Sciences at Edith
Cowan University, says that previous
24 | nursingreview.com.au
research indicated that a pandemic was
one of the situations that would likely
result in a decreased willingness to work
among paramedics.
“We have known for some time that
essential frontline workers would have
difficulty weighing up professional
obligation with personal risk when it came
to a situation like a pandemic,” she says.
“However, despite this obvious ethical
dilemma, clarification of an acceptable
level of personal risk for many healthcare
workers and essential frontline personnel –
like police officers – is still lacking.”
The Guardian has reported that doctors
and nurses in the UK are being “bullied
and shamed” into treating patients with
COVID-19 despite not having the masks,
gowns and eyewear they need to protect
themselves from the virus. They are also
being advised to hold their breath when
treating patients due to PPE shortages.
A perfect storm of a lack of
communication from management, a lack
of PPE, panic and low pay could come
together and cause an issue among the
nursing workforce, Smith says.
“I think we’re coming off the back
of an unprecedented bushfire season,
so psychologically we’ve already been
stretched to our limits. In terms of PPE,
we’ve used up a huge amount of our
existing stockpile, particularly in terms of
the face masks that we need.
“Here comes this pandemic of a brandnew
virus and we’re being asked to get
back up off the ground and start again. It’s
difficult because we know first-hand from
a lot of the people that I’m speaking to
that their hospitals are essentially gagging
their staff and saying, ‘You cannot speak to
the media. You cannot tell people what’s
happening’,” she says.
Smith adds that you only have to walk
down the corridors of Australian hospitals
now and you can see all the hand sanitiser
stations are empty, and nurses and doctors
are being told to use their PPE masks for
well beyond what the standard protocol
would usually be.
“That’s not out of a malicious kind of
direction from the hospital, it’s simply
because they are trying to ration what they
have,” Smith says. “It’s a bit of a perfect
storm because we’ve run out of the
stockpile. The government are working as
hard as they possibly can to replenish those
stockpiles, but it takes time.
“We need to remember that a lot of
those are coming in from overseas, ships
are being quarantined. There’s not as
many flights coming in. When they do
arrive, a lot of these have been waiting
for at least 14 days in isolation before
they can be a distributed. Then it’s that
interesting process of how we actually
divvy these up.
“The government announced [recently]
that 30 million masks arrived in the
country. But it would be very interesting
to see how long it takes before they are
actually on the faces of our frontline
healthcare workers, because there will be
that complex decision-making process
now of who actually gets them.”
In addition, Smith says that if health
workers attempt to speak out about PPE
shortages, they are threatened with losing
their job.
“What’s the priority matrix here, and
who makes those decisions? Because I’m
talking to nurses and I’m talking to GPs,
and they’re down to, if not weeks, days’
worth of supply left.
“They will be making very real decisions
very soon about, ‘My life and my health is
not worth my job. My job is not worth it’.”
Adding to this bubbling issue is the
accumulative psychological scarring the
nation has incurred after a long, hard