ROYAL COMMISSION
Prime Minster Scott Morrison.
Photo: AAP Image/Mick Tsikas.
Govt U-turn
Move to privatise Aged Care
Assessment Teams ditched.
By Conor Burke
T
he federal government has
announced that it will abandon its
controversial plan to privatise the
ACAT assessment process.
A communiqué released from the
recent COAG Health Council meeting
said: “The Commonwealth has confirmed
that it is not proceeding with the current
tender process. Over the longer term,
the Commonwealth will take advice from
states and territories and from the royal
commission about what the exact delivery
mix should be.”
This comes after months of anger from
the public, the sector and several politicians
over the plan, which some say would lower
the standard of assessment and focus on
profit over care.
Earlier this year, the federal government’s
state Liberal colleagues questioned the
logic of the plan. NSW Health Minister Brad
Hazzard claimed that at a meeting of state
and federal ministers there was no mention
of the plan.
“It seems pre-emptive and unreasonable
to be effectively privatising health aged-care
services while the royal commission into
aged care is still underway. Not a lot of logic
there,” reported The Sydney Morning Herald.
8 | nursingreview.com.au
Meanwhile, federal Liberal backbencher
Russell Broadbent recently told Parliament
that there was no justification for the
privatisation plan.
“I’ve been in situations where areas
have been contracted out in my past life
and there is a great loss of experience,”
Broadbent said.
In a rare statement, aged care royal
commissioner Tony Pagone came out
against the plan and rebuked Aged Care
Minister Richard Colbeck over his claims
that the royal commission advocated the
privatisation of the ACAT system.
“I take this opportunity to make clear
that the Interim Report did not endorse the
government’s stated position but noted
that we would monitor with interest the
implementation which the government had
announced,” he said.
“It is desirable in view of the public
concerns and statements which have been
expressed that it is made clear that the work
of royal commissioners is intended to be,
and is, independent of government.
“Our tasks as commissioners are detailed in
the terms of reference, and we have not yet
made recommendations about which sector
or mechanism will best achieve an integration
of Regional Assessment Services and the
Aged Care Assessment Teams.”
The Australian Nursing and Midwifery
Federation welcomed this about-face
and reiterated that any move to privatise
government aged care functions goes
against the findings that the royal
commission has made so far.
ANMF federal secretary Annie Butler said:
“The ANMF questioned why the federal
government’s pre-emptive decision was
made before the royal commission into
aged care had a chance to deliver final
recommendations.
“It would have affected existing
assessment services expertly delivered by
a skilled workforce of registered nurses,
geriatricians, allied health professionals,
social workers and others, jeopardising the
jobs of hundreds of skilled practitioners.
“And most importantly, consumers
in need of expert support could have
been directed to a for-profit provider, not
independent of the care provider, effectively
leading to the privatisation of ACAT, where
older members of the community in need
of care could have been placed at the
mercy of businesses.
“As has been clearly demonstrated by
the royal commission so far, the failures of
the ‘market’ in aged care are profound. The
ANMF was therefore deeply concerned that
these failures would spread to ACAT and
destroy this expert service.
“We are very pleased that the COAG
health ministers’ meeting has reversed
the federal government’s decision, and
we thank all of those who advocated to
retain ACAT and maintain a focus on safety,
respect, reassurance and continuity of care
for our elderly.”
Queensland’s Health Minister Steven
Miles has also welcomed the news, as any
planned changes to ACAT “was bad for
The failures of the
‘market’ in aged care are
profound.
patients waiting in hospital for an aged
care place, and because more than 250
Queensland jobs were at risk”, he said.
“We are pleased the Commonwealth has
heard our concerns and will work with the
states to ensure aged care assessments are
undertaken by the public system.
“The royal commission has so far found
that the Morrison government is failing our
elderly Queenslanders.
“The last thing Australia’s aged care
system needed was more privatisation. A lot
still needs to be done to fix aged care, but
we welcome this announcement today.”
Aged Care Minister Richard Colbeck was
contacted for comment. ■