clinical practice
Eventually, what I want to look at is all
the predictors and the context for how
nurses will respond. But to get there,
I had to figure out what the responses
probably even would be, in terms of big
global kinds of intentions. And so this study
then attempted to unpack one aspect of
the larger study, and that was the range
of intention.
Most of the literature around nurses’
approaches to participating in assisted
dying around the world where legal, or
even where it’s not legal, has focused
on their willingness to even participate,
whatever form of assisted dying was
prevalent in that country, and as if it were
a yes or no decision.
But looking between the lines of a lot
of these studies, it was apparent that it
wasn’t just a yes or no option, that there
were actually many options, and those had
never been explored. And so in between
yes and no there is a whole lot of grey
areas. And that is where I think most nurses
actually tend to be. My hypothesis is that
most nurses don’t know what they intend
to do. And so I just wanted to find out.
Who did you look at? How many nurses,
and were they already in areas where
voluntary assisted dying was in place?
This particular study interviewed 45
Australian nurses who were advanced
practitioners in a variety of clinical areas –
not necessarily where assisted dying was
legal, but from across Australia.
They completed a unique type of
survey where they had to rank in order
their preferences for different sorts of
statements. So it wasn’t a survey in the
sense of a Likert scale – I strongly agree,
strongly disagree – it was more complex.
It was a lot of work, and I really appreciate
the time those 45 nurses put into it.
You received four distinct types of
intentions to respond to requests.
There was ‘refer and support’, ‘object
to or deflect their request’, ‘engage and
explore the request’, or ‘assess needs and
provide information’.
The ‘refer and support’ is probably the
most active intention a nurse would
have. Say that they were responding to a
scenario where a person who was known
to them, a patient who had a terminal
illness, asked for the first time about
access to assisted dying. How was the
nurse going to respond to that request?
And so when it came to the option of
‘I will help this person and refer this
request onto their doctor’, this is typically
the kind of support that a patient who is
seeking assisted dying would expect from
a nurse.
But not all nurses would expect to have
to deliver that response. Interestingly, the
majority of the nurses did say that this is
the response that they would probably
intend to deliver.
For nurses who do object, or want
to deflect the patient’s requests, this
suggests the public may have trouble
getting access to these drugs. How likely
is that outcome?
Well, that outcome is possible. But it’s not
particularly likely from the perspective
of the nurses themselves. Because most
nurses are able to engage with that request
whether or not it coheres with their own
particular moral stance.
There is a distinct minority, about
2 per cent of nurses in Australia, that I
can assess so far who might let their own
objection to legal assisted dying get in the
way of working with that person, and they
would be what is called in the literature
‘conscientious objectors’.
Now, those people are not likely to
interfere with a person’s ability to access
the service. What is more likely to interfere
with that is the place where that nurse
works. Because a lot of hospices, or
a lot of areas where people are at the
end of their lives, are often faith-based
organisations. And as a function of
their denominated religious affiliation,
they are almost always opposed to
assisted dying.
And what we’ve seen overseas is that
even though a nurse may support assisted
dying, may support this patient’s right to
it, they can lose their job if they help the
patient to realise what they want. It’s less
about the nurses than about the employers
of nurses.
Do we need nurse training to include
more of this work, and work on the
ethical implications of VAD laws?
Yes. I think there’s almost always a course
on bioethics in any of these training
programs.
There will obviously need to be more
attention paid to a self-reflection about
where a person stands with regard to
this. But also training about what the
law actually requires, because there’s
still quite a bit of confusion around that.
And also just practising responding. One
of the things I really learned was from one
of my interviews with a nurse practitioner
who managed organ donation in a large
urban teaching hospital. She said the thing
that helped her team prepare for these
difficult conversations was lots of practice
simulation in professional development
work. So the more people are exposed
to it, think about it, and practise it, the
stronger their intentions become, whatever
those intentions are.
What does your study tell us and what do
you think are the main implications for
nursing practice?
Basically, it tells us that the intention to
respond to a patient’s request is not a
binary intention. That it’s quite complex,
it’s complicated. So it’s not an abstract
or academic question so much, but
Even though a nurse
may support assisted dying ...
they can lose their job if they
help the patient.
there’s this complex area between yes
and no where nurses have to respond,
and there are many ways to make
those responses.
The second half of my study is going
to be what predicts those. But I had to
figure out what those were first.
Your PhD is looking into this in general.
Can you tell us a bit about that, and
where you’re going next?
Now that I understand the range of
intentions that nurses in Australia might
have for responding to these requests,
what is really needed to develop the
professional development for nurses, and
the preparation for it, is to understand
what will predict these responses. Is it
their attitude towards assisted dying?
Is it what their colleagues think, or
what their family thinks? Is it their
own sense of competence, or self-
efficacy, in being able to manage this
situation? Is it their private, personal,
moral conviction?
All of these things come together to
predict these kinds of intention. And it sort
of focuses on a moment of truth for the
nurse who has to confront this question,
which is going to become a more frequent
part of nursing practice as the decade
rolls on and this becomes a common
phenomenon across Australia. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 25