Military Review English Edition March-April 2016 | Page 125
MR BOOK REVIEWS
CREATING KOSOVO: International Oversight and
the Making of Ethical Institutions
Elton Skendaj, Cornell University Press, New York,
2014, 248 pages
K
osovo remains an experiment in progress seventeen years after the Rambouillet Accords
and the issuance of United Nations Security
Council Resolution 1244, authorizing international
civil and military forces in Kosovo to end the violence,
reestablish governance, and enable security in the
region. Creating Kosovo: International Oversight and the
Making of Ethical Institutions is an
informative and thought-provoking
book that investigates how international and local actors have built
state bureaucracies and democratic
institutions in Kosovo.
This book, structured as a comparative research study, is well organized and easy to follow. Unlike other
literary works on Kosovo that focus on
broad aspects of state building, Elton
Skendaj, an assistant professor at the
University of Miami and a former
European studies research scholar at
the Wilson Center, examines in detail
the effectiveness of select core bureaucracies within Kosovo. He explores the
court system, customs service, police
force, and central administration, while simultaneously
analyzing the progress of democratic reforms in elections,
civil society, the media, and the legislature.
Skendaj posits that state building and democratization by international actors are two different processes
that require complementary but different approaches
to build and sustain effective bureaucracies. To support
his hypothesis, he argues, “effective bureaucracies can
be built when local actors take ownership of the institutions or international actors insulate the bureaucracy
MILITARY REVIEW March-April 2016
form political influence.” Additionally, Skendaj argues,
“democratic progress is more likely when citizens
mobilize for regime change, citizens are demobilized, as
authoritarian liberal elites negotiate for regime change,
and coalitions of international and local actors jointly
support regime change.”
The author skillfully creates a realistic narrative on the
challenges of building effective state institutions in postconflict environments. He does this by using data from
numerous authoritative sources to support his analysis of
various institutions in Kosovo: one hundred fifty formal
interviews, internal and official government reports, strategies of international organizations, government agencies,
nongovernmental agencies, and public surveys. Using the
indicators of mission fulfillment, penalization for corruption, and responsiveness, Skendaj illustrates the various
factors to create variances in institutional effectiveness caused by local,
national, and international actors.
One of the most intriguing aspects
of this book is his analysis of how
international actors have prematurely
demobilized citizens and hindered
their participation in the democratic
process, inadvertently undermining
the accountability of political leaders
to the citizens of Kosovo. Skendaj is
clearly at his best in the closing chapter
of the book, applying aspects of his
analysis of institutions and state building policy in Kosovo to other countries, including Bosnia, East Timor, Georgia, Singapore,
Sierra Leone, Iraq, and Afghanistan.
This book contains useful figures and tables that help
support the analysis, and an extensive reference section.
I highly recommend this well-written and documented
book to both researchers and midgrade to senior-level
military officers and government officials involved in
developing postconflict strategies and policies.
Lt. Col. Edward D. Jennings, U.S. Army,
Retired, Leavenworth, Kansas
123