Med Achievers July 2014 | Page 24

damages   and   in   cases   of   gross   negligence,   may   result   in   criminal   liability.     The   Hon’ble   Courts   of   India   have,   in   some   cases   awarded   hefty   compensation   to   the   patients   and   the   said   compensation   is   measured   on   account   of   life,   loss   of   future   earning,   physical   and   mental   pain   and   suffering   faced   by   the   complainant   .   Given,   the   number   of   medical   negligence   cases   is   on  rise  in  India,  the  Apex  Court  has  set  a   milestone   in   fixing   the   liability   for   medical   negligence   by   awarding   compensation   of   Rs.   6   crores   in   Kunal   Saha  case.   However,   with   the   increasing   frivolous   complaints  against  doctors,  it  should  be   understood   that   the   doctors   should   not   be   harassed   merely   because   their   treatment   was   unsuccessful   and   had   caused   some   mishap   not   necessarily   amounting  to  medical  negligence.  In  the   leading   case,   the   court   observed   that   “     In   the   matter   of   professional   liability   professions   differ   from   other   occupations   for   the   reason   that   professions   operate   in   spheres   where   success   cannot   be   achieved   in   every   case   and   very   often   success   or   failure   depends   upon   factors   beyond   the   professional  man's  control.”   It   is   to   be   noted   that   a   balance   need   to   be   struck   in   cases   of   medical   negligence,   where   the   doctors   who   has   caused   death  or  serious  agony  to  patients  need   to   be   penalized,   but   it   must   also   be   remembered   that   like   all   professional   the   doctors   too   can   make   errors   of   judgment   but   if   they   are   punished   for   this   then   no   doctor   can   practice   their   vocation  with  equanimity.     Conclusion   Today,   the   patient-­‐   centred   initiative   of   rights   protection   is   required   to   be   appreciated   in   the   economic   context   of   decreasing   state   spending   and   increasing   private   investment   in   health   care   sector   and   the   continuous   efforts   by   Hon’ble   Courts   of   India   to   constitutionalize   the   right   to   health   as   fundamental   right   need   to   be   recognized.   However,   it   is   essential   to   note  that  the  rights  of  patients  shall  not   be   protected   at   cost   of   professional   integrity   and   autonomy.   There   need   to   strike   a   delicate   balance;   otherwise   the   consequences  will  be  inexplicable.