Med Achievers July 2014 | Page 23

breach   of   duty   by   doctors   and   its   causation.   If   the   complainant   is   able   to   prove   that   the   injury   suffered   by   him/her  is  due  to  the  negligence  on  part   of   a   doctor   in   excising   the   duty   of   care   and  doctor’s  failure  to  act  in  accordance   with   the   standards   of   reasonably   competent   medical   men   which   he   should  have  exercised  at  that  time,  then   the   doctor   may   be   held   liable   for   negligence.   Normally,   the   liability   for   medical   negligence   arises   only   when   the   complainant   is   able   to   discharge   the   burden   on   him   of   proving   medical   negligence.     Charges  of  Medical  Negligence     Though,  the  cases  of  medical  negligence   is   increasing   rapidly   in   India,   the   amount   of   frivolous   complaints   against   doctors   have   also   increased   exponentially.   A   medical   professional   may  be  held  liable  for  negligence  when;   • • He   was   not   possessed   of   the   requisite  skill  which  he  professed   to  have  possessed;   He   did   not   exercise,   with   reasonable   competence   in   the   given   case,   the   skill,   which   he   did   possess.   Mere  error  of  judgment  by  doctors  does   not   arises   the   liability   of   doctor   only   if   decision   taken   by   doctor   is   in   due   consideration   of   all   the   facts   and   circumstances   of   the   case.   Failure   of   operation   and   side   effects   of   treatment   cannot   amount   to   negligence   by   the   doctors.   The   doctor   may   not   be   held   liable   for   negligence   because   someone   else   of   better   skill   or   knowledge   would   have   prescribed   a   different   method   of   operation  in  different  way.     So   long   as   a   doctor   follows   a   practice   acceptable   to   the   medical   profession   of   that   day,   he   cannot   be   held   liable   for   negligence.  The  Courts  in  India  may  held   doctor   liable   for   medical   negligence,   only  if  he  has  fallen  short  of  standard  of   reasonable  medical  care.   The   Complainant,   in   cases   of   medical   negligence   needs   to   prove   the   allegation   of   negligence   by   adducing   reliable   evidence   and   has   to   be   supported   by   expert   evidence.   The   burden   of   proving   the   case   of   medical   negligence   lies   on   the  patient.     Cases  of  Medical  Negligence     The  Consumer  Protection  Act,  1986  has   given   the   comprehensive   definition   for   deficiency   in   services   and   with   the   landmark   judgment   of   Indian   medical   Association   vs.   V.P   Shantha,   the   treatment   provided   by   doctors   comes   within   the   ambit   o f   service   under   Consumer   Protection   Act,   1986.   Both   cases   civil   and   criminal   as   well   before   consumer   forum   are   filed   against   medical   practitioners   and   hospitals   complaining   of   medical   negligence   against  doctors.     The   Complainant   is   required   to   prove   the   allegations   of   medical   negligence   against   doctors/   hospitals   and   thereafter,   if   the   medical   practitioners   are   held   liable   for   negligence,   it   may   result   in   civil   liability   in   form   of