• The structure you choose today affects the value of your agency later •
FEATURE
• Owners in S corporations may show lower payroll expense if they take part of their income as distributions instead of W2 wages
• Owners in LLCs may show higher net income because they do not run compensation through payroll
• C corporations may retain earnings in the business, which makes their income statement look different from an S corporation
Partnership structures may split profit in ways that do not match how roles and responsibilities are shared.
When you compare EBITDA, profit margin, or producer compensation across agencies with different structures, the numbers can look higher or lower for reasons that have nothing to do with performance.
This is why AgencyFocus normalizes financials during valuations and benchmarking. Structure differences need to be adjusted so owners can compare apples to apples.
Understanding the structure behind another agency helps you avoid drawing the wrong conclusions. A weaker structure can make a strong agency look weak, and a strong structure can make a weak agency look strong.
BRINGING IT ALL TOGETHER
• Your structure impacts how you pay yourself, how much tax you owe, and how complex your operations become
• Transitions should be made intentionally, not reactively
• Benchmarking and valuations only work when structure differences are understood and adjusted
• The structure you choose today affects the value of your agency later •
Lindsay Sexton is the Director of Agency Growth for AgencyFocus and has over five years of experience working with agencies on planning and services.
Aaron Stocks is the Founder and Chief Executive Officer of PFS Global, where he leads a multidisciplinary team across its financial, tax, and human resources operations. He has over 15 years of experience working with independent agencies and other business owners.
SELECTIVE IS THRILLED TO BE OPEN FOR STANDARD COMMERCIAL LINES BUSINESS IN KANSAS
Most independent agencies follow a predictable path. They start as an LLC because it offers protection and simplicity. When profits rise and operations stabilize, many transition to S corporation taxation. A smaller group remains C corporations due to legacy reasons or specialized planning.
There is no perfect structure for every agency. The right choice depends on your profit level, long term plans, number of owners, and how willing you are to maintain the systems each structure requires.
The most important things for agency owners to understand are:
© 2025 Selective Ins. Group, Inc., Branchville, NJ. Products vary by jurisdiction, terms and conditions and are provided by Selective Ins. Co. of America and its insurer affiliates. Details at selective. com / about / affiliated-insurers. aspx. SI-25-1148
JANUARY / FEBRUARY 2026
9