Journal of Academic Development and Education JADE Issue 9 | Page 10
HIGHLIGHT #1 | 11
10 | JADE
GEMMA WITTON
Marchand, J., Pearson, M., & Albon, S. (2014). Student and faculty member
perspectives on lecture capture in pharmacy education. American Journal of
Pharmaceutical Education, 78(4), 74.
Powers, C.A. and Carrol, M.A. (2016) Student Attendance at Pharmacology
Lectures and Its Relation to Exam Performance: A Two Year Observational
Analysis. The FASEB Journal, 31:810.4
Witton, G. (2017) The value of capture: taking an alternative approach to using
lecture capture technologies for increased impact on student learning and
engagement. British Journal of Educational Technology, 48: 1010–1019. DOI:
10.1111/bjet.12470the same?
HIGHLIGHT #1
Title
“What makes good
teaching?”: Reflections from a
Teaching Fellow in Law
Author
Stella Coyle
DOI
http://dx.doi.org/10.21252/
KEELE-0000021
Contact
[email protected]
Keele University
I became a Teaching Fellow
in September 2016 and it was
recommended that I undertake
the Teaching and Learning in
Higher Education programme
(TLHEP). I wasn’t completely
new to university teaching; I
had been a Graduate Teaching
Assistant for three years
while researching my PhD,
with positive feedback from
students and peer review from
colleagues. I confess to having
been somewhat sceptical as
to what the TLHEP could offer
me, and wary of the additional
workload on top of a new job
with a busy timetable. However,
as the course progressed, I
appreciated having dedicated
time to reflect critically on
my teaching, and I discovered
how theories of learning
and teaching could help me
make more informed choices
about how I teach. This is
what Brookfield means by
the ‘deeper benefit’ of critical
reflection in addition to mere
‘procedural utility’, because
critical reflection leads us to
‘know why we believe what we
believe’. 1
This discussion on ‘What
makes good teaching?’ is from
my first TLHEP assignment.
Like any student looking back
on work she wrote last year,
I am very aware how much I
have learnt since then and I am
therefore a little shy of sharing
it! I hope readers will find it
interesting nevertheless.
What makes good
teaching?
It can be difficult to define
what makes good teaching,
not least because teaching is
‘a complex act, influenced by
subtle conditions and swift
teacher-student interactions’. 2
I have strong memories of
certain teachers throughout
my life: for example, the
primary
school
teacher
who encouraged me to
read Orwell; the high school
physics teacher whose vivid
explanation of force remains
with me 35 years later; the
university
lecturer
who
managed to make contract
law interesting through his use
of entertaining stories; and
the master’s lecturer whose
eccentricities of dress and
personality
complemented
his ability to make us question
our assumptions. Students
remember
good
teachers
for a variety of reasons, but
there are several factors that
contribute towards what is
generally understood to be
good teaching. This discussion
draws on both the academic
literature and on personal
reflection from my own
teaching experience so far.
The
overarching
aim
of
successful teaching, for me, is
to provide a collaborative and
enriching learning experience
which
enables
students
to achieve their goals. An
important ingredient in this
1. Stephen Brookfield, ‘The Getting of Wisdom: What Critically Reflective
Teaching is and Why It’s Important,’ in Becoming a Critically Reflective
Teacher (1995): 1-28, 25.
2. Allan C Ornstein, ‘The New Paradigm in Research on Teaching,’ The
Educational Forum 59.2 (1995): 124.