Journal of Academic Development and Education JADE Issue 11 Summer 2019 | Page 10
Highlight #2 Reflections on student diversity: the
overlooked case of "the Chinese
learner"
Reflections on
student diversity: the
overlooked case of
"the Chinese learner" I teach on the BSc Environment & Sustainability programme at
Keele, which has a collaborative version linking with Nanjing
Xiaozhuang University (NXU) in China. Students undertake
3 years’ study at NXU and then come to Keele for a final
year alongside students on the standard programme. During
their second and third years NXU students take bridging
modules taught by Keele staff, in English, either via distance
learning or in person in China. These students share specific
challenges in the transition to learning here in the UK that,
whilst representing a group characteristic needing recognition,
also risk stereotyping “Chinese learners” as a homogenous
group (Gu & Schweisfurth, 2006). Language barriers and being
used to assessment only by exam can give a false impression
from early interactions with staff of problematic engagement
with learning and academic ability. These impressions risk
seeding unconscious biases that may negatively affect both
student experiences of interactions with staff and assessment
outcomes. In the context of increasing internationalisation of
higher education and connected diversity issues (see: Altbach &
Knight, 2007; Andrade, 2006; Caruana & Ploner, 2011; Ennew
& Fujia, 2009; Healey, 2008; Zhou et al., 2008), this raises
important issues regarding student diversity. Importantly for me,
there appeared in my early stages of teaching NXU students to
be a gap between perceptions and achievement - with amongst
the best dissertations I was marking being by NXU students.
Author: A. Moolna
DOI:
doi.org/10.21252/
g7qn-n645
Contact:
[email protected]
The construct of “the Chinese learner” is widely used in the
literature and presents an implicit deficit model stereotyping
Chinese students as lacking critical reasoning skills and
autonomy, being passive and reliant on the teacher as a
transmitter of rote-learnt knowledge (Grimshaw, 2007). Deficit
models explain the underperformance of minorities as being
due to intrinsic characteristics of learners in those groups. Work
towards equality and diversity has, however, recognised that
attainment gaps are due principally to a environmental factors
including barriers to learning and unconscious bias, as best
developed for gender and race (Cotton et al., 2015). Inclusive
education reforms have drawn parallels with the social model
of disability central to ongoing work for equality for disabled
students (Terzi, 2004). The Athena SWAN (Scientific Women's
Academic Network) programme of the Equality Challenge Unit
(ECU) is the most prominent UK sectoral equality initiative
(followed internationally as best practice; Gibney, 2017). The
ECU followed Athena SWAN with a Race Equality Charter, of
which Keele University is a member, and discuss in Caruana
& Ploner (2011) equality and diversity issues that come with
10