Journal of Academic Development and Education JADE Issue 10 | Page 34
JADE | 34
ARTICLE #2
Title
The Impact of a Career and
Technical Education on the
Graduation Rates and College
Enrollment of High School
Students
Authors
Rona Walker* & Aarek Farmer
* Career and Technical Education
Educator, Freed-Hardeman
University, 6285 Covington Pike
Rd, Millington, TN 38053, (901)
268-4357
Assistant Professor, Academic
Director, Director of Ed. D.
in Instructional Leadership,
Freed-Hardeman University, 6285
Covington Pike Rd, Millington, TN
38053, (901) 268-4357
DOI
http://dx.doi.org/10.21252/
KEELE-0000030
Contact
[email protected]
Keywords
College and Career Readiness;
graduation rate; college enrollment
Abstract
Context
and
Objectives.:
This study explored the
impact Career and Technical
Education (CTE) had on high
school students in Tennessee.
Specifically, the purpose of
this quantitative study was
to compare graduation rates
and college enrollment rates
between CTE concentrators
and non-concentrators.
Methods:
The
researcher
examined existing data from
39 schools in West Tennessee
from the 2013-14 and 2014–15
years provided by districts
CTE departments.
Results: Results indicated that
CTE concentrators were more
likely to graduate high school
and enroll in postsecondary
education
than
were
non-concentrators.
Discussion and Conclusion:
CTE can be a significant
component of high school
education and is connected
to measurable success for
students of all backgrounds.
Schools
should
consider
expanding opportunities for
students to gain knowledge
directly related to their career
interests and strengths.
Introduction
The United States high school
graduation rate was a record
84% in 2016, which was the
highest
percentage
since
states adopted a new uniform
way of calculating graduation
rates (National Center for
Education Statistics [NCES],
2017). Seventy-six percent
of black students graduated
on time and 79% of Hispanic
students graduated on time
compared to 88% of white
students and 91% of Asian/
Pacific
Islander
students
(Balingit 2017).
Although minority groups saw
a rise in on-time graduation
rates in 2016, gaps persist
for low-income and minority
students and students with
disabilities. Semuels (2016)
argued
that
inequities
between wealthier and poorer
districts continue to exist in
all states across the United
States. Kearney and Levine
(2016) found that one-quarter
or more of boys who started
high school in the higher
inequality states of Louisiana,
Mississippi, Georgia, and the
District Columbia failed to
graduate in a four-year period,
compared to 10% percent in
Vermont, Wisconsin, North
Dakota, and Nebraska; lower
inequality states. Moreover,
Layton (2014) suggested that
it is not unusual for major cities
to experience a higher dropout
rate and lower graduation rate
than states.
Context and Objectives
This study was designed to
examine the impact of Career
and Technical Education (CTE)
on CTE concentrators and
non-concentrators. CTE refers
to a program in which courses
(both at the high school
and the postsecondary sub-
baccalaureate levels) focus
on the skills and knowledge
required for specific jobs
or fields of work. The
ARTICLE #2 | 35
THE IMPACT OF A CAREER AND TECHNICAL EDUCATION ON
THE GRADUATION RATES AND COLLEGE ENROLLMENT OF HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
occupational fields may include: (a) agriculture and natural resources,
(b) business support, management, and finance, (c) communications
and design, (d) computer and information sciences, (e) construction,
(f) consumer services, (g) education, (h) engineering, architecture,
and science technologies, (i) health sciences, (j) manufacturing, (k)
marketing, (l) public, legal, social, and protective services, (m) repair,
(n) and transportation. At the high school level, CTE is sometimes
expanded beyond "occupational education" to include family and
consumer sciences education and courses that provide general
labor market skills. Effective Career and Technical Education (CTE)
programs allow students to earn dual enrollment credits, industry-
endorsed certificates, and technical endorsements while earning
high school diplomas (Plank, DeLuca, & Estacion, 2005). Although
the United States high school graduation rate has increased in recent
years, differences exist by race and ethnicity, socioeconomic status,
immigration status and state (American Institutes for Research,
2016). The 2013 dropout rates for Asian and Caucasian 16- to
24-year-olds were lower than their African American and Hispanic
students. Lynch (2016) noted since the National Center for Education
Statistics started tracking different groups of high school students in
the late 1960s, the socioeconomic status of each pupil has impacted
the graduation rate. Students from low-income families are 2.4 times
more likely to drop out than middle-income students, and more than
10 times more likely to drop out than their high-income peers.
Methods
A quantitative research method was used to gather existing
data regarding graduation rates of CTE concentrators and non-
concentrators. Concentrators were considered students who took
three or more CTE courses, while non-concentrators were students
who took less than three CTE courses. The following research
questions guided the study.
1. Is there a significant difference between the graduation rates
of Career and Technical Education concentrators and non-
concentrator students?
2. Is there a relationship between college enrollment and the
completion of a Career and Technical Education (CTE) program?
This study explored (a) whether CTE concentrators were more
likely to graduate from high school than non-concentrators and (b)
whether more CTE concentrators continued on to postsecondary
education than their non-concentrators counterparts. Data from a
total of 1470 students were included in the study, of which 479 (32.8%)
were CTE concentrators and 991 (67.2%) were non-concentrators
from the 2013–2014 school year. Additionally, in the 2014–2015
school year, a total of 1455 students were selected for this analysis.