HPE 100 – March 2022 | Page 16

one of these ‘ wastes ’. Much of clinical pharmacy could be deemed ‘ waste ’, 19 and where there is insufficient staffing that valuable commodity could be better used by supporting the ‘ getting it right first time ’ ( GIRFT ) approach . The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence guidance on medicines optimisation , which superseded the original medicines reconciliation guidance , requires medicines to be reconciled but does not specify it as a pharmacy role . 20 Should the profession be driving better use of technology and different use of staff to support this GIRFT agenda and release our time to support the active prescribing agenda , rather than correcting the transcription of medicines on admission and discharge ?
More recently , the evidence base describing patient outcomes related to pharmaceutical care is in the area of pharmacist attendance on ward rounds . 21 23 The work of Gray et al describes the deployment of individual pharmacists to single dedicated wards , facilitating the attendance on ward rounds and with time spent afterwards on the ward communicating medicines related information for onward patient care . 21 This service demonstrated associations with earlier in the day discharge , reduced length of stay and reduced readmission rates . In the critical care specialty , the PROTECTED study 22 also highlighted the impact of pharmacists attending ward rounds and the subsequent paper 23 identified that many sites were not staffed to the recommended levels to facilitate this level of service delivery . In Australia , further evidence supporting this approach was published last year . 24 Is this an additional task to add to the activity standard ? Or is it simply a different way to deploy staff to deliver the same tasks ? If the wards at the hospital in the paper by Gray et al are applied to the CPWC , the staff resource identified is 1.2 pharmacists per ward ( accounting for the unavailable time ); this matches the resource requirement used by Gray et al – and does the staff deployment in this way address the GIRFT issues , complete the task list , and allow extension of tasks due to time released to care from GIRFT ?
Next steps The study by Bednall et al 12 demonstrated the practicality of standardising the identification of evidence-based staffing levels for pharmacy services , which can be applied to different settings and services internationally . As a profession we should come in line with other health professions in identifying the required staffing levels for our service to remove unwarranted variation . To do so , we need to confirm the ‘ activity standard ’ for our services ensuring that quality outcomes for our patients are maintained . Where staffing levels cannot be achieved using existing pharmacist workforce , perhaps we need to consider changing the scope of practice for our supporting staff groups such as pharmacy technicians .
Conclusion The challenge for the pharmacy profession is to be agile enough to adapt our service model and staffing approach to deliver efficient care , moving away from traditional models of dispensary-based roles or peripatetic lone practitioners , correcting mistakes to a more holistic and MDT approach to care supporting other practitioners in the GIRFT agenda . We need to describe these activities clearly and staff them appropriately – and develop the evidence base that demonstrates the value added to patient care by high quality pharmacy services .
KEY POINTS
• A methodology for identifying pharmacy staffing levels has been proved .
• Staffing levels do not match theoretical levels in practice and the implications of this on patient care is not known .
• The evidence base of the benefit of clinical pharmacy is dated and needs . refreshing to understand the current impact of clinical service models .
• If the activity standard for the profession is confirmed through new evidence , there is insufficient capacity in current staffing to provide these services and up-skilling the pharmacy technician workforce will be necessary .
• Pharmacy needs to be agile in adopting new service models based firmly in the multi-disciplinary team to best serve our patients .
References 1 Hepler C , Strand L . Opportunities and responsibilities in pharmaceutical care . Am J Hosp Pharm 1990 ; 47:533 – 43 . 2 Bond C , Raehl C . Clinical pharmacy services , pharmacy staffing , and hospital mortality rates . Pharmacotherapy 2007 ; 27:481 – 93 . 3 Gallagher J et al . Cost-outcome description of clinical pharmacist interventions in a university teaching hospital . BMC Health Serv Res 2014 ; 14:177 . 4 Gammie T , Vogler S , Babar Z . Economic Evaluation of Hospital and Community Pharmacy Services : A Review of the Literature ( 2010 – 2015 ). Ann Pharmacother 2017 ; 51:54 – 65 . 5 Lord Carter of Coles . Operational productivity and performance in English NHS acute hospitals : Unwarranted variations . An independent report for the Department of Health . 2016 . www . gov . uk / government / publications / productivity-innhs-hospitals ( accessed January 2022 ). 6 NHS Benchmarking Network . National Hospital Pharmacy Benchmarking Programme 2018-19 . 2019 . https :// s3 . eu-west-2 . amazonaws . com / nhsbnstatic / Pharmacy % 20 &% 20Medicines % 20 Optimisation / 2019 / Summary % 20Report . pdf ( accessed January 2022 ). 7 National Quality Board . Supporting NHS providers to deliver the right
staff , with the right skills , in the right place at the right time Safe sustainable and productive staffing July 2016 . www . england . nhs . uk / wp-content / uploads / 2013 / 04 / nqb-guidance . pdf ( accessed January 2022 ). 8 World Health Organization . Workload Indicators of staffing need [ WISN ] User ’ s Manual . Geneva : 2010 . www . who . int / hrh / resources / WISN _ Eng _ UsersManual . pdf ( accessed January 2022 ). 9 McQuide P , Kolehmainen-Aitken R , Forster N . Applying the workload indicators of staffing need [ WISN ] method in Namibia : challenges and implications for human resources for health policy . Human Resources Health 2013 ; 11:64 . 10 Hagopian A et al . Applying WHO ’ s ‘ workforce indicators of staffing need ’ [ WISN ] method to calculate the health worker requirements for India ’ s maternal and child health service guarantees in Orissa State . Health Policy Plan 2012 ; 27:11 – 18 . 11 World Health Organization . Applying the WISN Method in Practice : Case studies from Indonesia , Mozambique and Uganda . 2010 Geneva : WHO Press . www . who . int / hrh / resources / wisn _ case _ studies / en / ( accessed January 2022 ). 12 Bednall R et al . Validation of a hospital clinical pharmacy workforce calculator : A methodology for pharmacy ? Int J Clin
Pract 2021 ; 75 ( 5 ): e13932 . 13 UK Government . Mental Health Act 2007 . www . legislation . gov . uk / ukpga / 2007 / 12 / contents ( accessed January 2022 ). 14 O ’ Leary K , Stuchbery P , Taylor G . Clinical Pharmacist Staffing Levels Needed to Deliver Clinical Services in Australian Hospitals . J Pharm Prac Res 2010 ; 40:217 – 21 . 15 Onatade R , Miller G , Sanghera I . A quantitative comparison of ward-based clinical pharmacy activities in 7 acute UK hospitals . Int J Clin Pharm 2016 ; 38 : 1407 – 15 . 16 EAHP Survey 2010 . Hospital Pharmacy Practice in Europe www . eahp . eu / sites / default / files / files / EAHP % 20 Survey % 202010 ( 1 ). pdf ( accessed January 2022 ). 17 Hussain H , Lewis N . Baseline study to investigate the ability of Band 5 hospital pharmacy technicians to prioritise patients through identification of medication issues on inpatient medication charts . Pharmacy Education 2020 ; 20 ( 1 ): 259 . https :// pharmacyeducation . fip . org / pharmacyeducation / article / view / 1121 / 930 ( accessed January 2022 ). 18 Ohno , T . The Toyota Production System : Beyond Large-Scale Production 1988 : Portland , Productivity Press . 19 Green C et al . A waste walk through
clinical pharmacy : how do the ‘ seven wastes ’ of Lean techniques apply to the practice of clinical pharmacists Int J Pharm Pract 2015 ; 23 ( 1 ): 21 – 6 . 20 National Institute for Health and Care Excellence . Medicines optimisation : the safe and effective use of medicines to enable the best possible outcomes . NG5 04 March 2015 . www . nice . org . uk / guidance / ng5 ( accessed January 2022 ). 21 Gray A Wallet J , Fletcher N . Dedicated ward pharmacists make an impact 2017 https :// hospitalpharmacyeurope . com / news / editors-pick / dedicated-wardpharmacists-make-an-impact / 22 Rudall N et al ; on behalf of the PROTECTED-UK group . Clinical pharmacist interventions in the UK critical care unit : exploration of relationship between intervention , service characteristics and experience level Int J Pharm Pract 2017 ; 25 ( 4 ): 311 – 19 . 23 Borthwick M et al . Critical care pharmacy workforce : UK deployment and characteristics in 2015 . Int J Pharm Pract 2018 ; 26 ( 4 ): 325 – 33 . 24 English S et al . Is ward round participation by clinical pharmacists a valuable use of time and money ? A time and motion study . Res Social Adm Pharm 2020 ; 16 ( 8 ): 1026 – 32 .
16 | Issue 100 | hospitalpharmacyeurope . com