Heat Exchanger World Magazine May 2023 | Page 21

Materials

Heat exchanger tubes in super austenitic stainless steels : A choice between duplex steels and high nickel alloyed steels for wet corrosion

This article elaborates the need to discuss super austenitic stainless steels as an alternative to options mentioned below .
By Venkat Ramesh , Global Product Manager ( Heat Exchanger tubing ), and Shabareesh Nair , Director ( Technical Marketing Asia ), Tubacex Group
Introductory background High Nickel alloyed stainless steels are categorized as having Chromium + Nickel greater than 50 %, and most of these alloys have Nickel greater than 30 %. These materials have been used widely in petrochemical , chemical , refinery , and organic acid industries , due to their excellent overall corrosion resistance to various types of media and harsh environments involving high temperatures . In recent months , there have been challenges faced by supply chain to procure these types of materials which have seen wide fluctuations in prices , and long leadtimes . This also adds to costs and budgets of major projects involving such materials , and sometimes leads to material selection changes to inferior alloys . This has resulted in an increase in OPEX cost and unplanned shutdowns in various applications . Austenitic stainless steels , on other hand , are not subjected to such high prices and lead times , but in applications involving severe corrosion , they are not suitable for use , and if used will have very short life . Duplex steels have been used widely over past years as an alternative to austenitic steels , due to its superior corrosion resistance under certain conditions . But , the major drawback has been its limited temperature zone within which equipment can be operated . Additionally , there are also issues with stress relieving heat treatment post U-bending .
Description Super austenitic stainless steels , by definition , are steel grades with PREN number ( as calculated by formula PREN = % Cr + 3.3 x % Mo + 16 x % N ) greater than 35 . These can also be classified as Cr-Ni-Mo steels , or Cr-Ni-Mo-Cu steels , having most Chromium content between 17 and 25 %, nickel between 14 and 25 %, and Molybdenum between 3 and 7 %. Many of these grades are also alloyed with nitrogen to further increase corrosion resistance and strength . Some grades are alloyed with copper to increase resistance to certain acids . It also has fully austenitic grain structure in annealed condition , good cold and hot workability , and is easy to weld . Some of the grades this paper elaborates on in detail are super austenitic , mentioned in Table 1 .
Wet corrosion properties Pitting corrosion Pitting is localized corrosion in a pattern of rat holes penetrating through the tube wall . The initializing of pitting depends on several factors , such as presence corrosive environment ( e . g ., Halides-Chlorides , Bromides , and Fluorides ), temperature , and most importantly , the defects and weakness of the steel passive protective layer . Once pitting initiates , the propagation is much faster . Prescence of higher % of Chromium in stainless steels helps in pitting corrosion resistance as forms a strong
Steel Grade , Chemical Composition ( Key Elements )
Common Grade name
International Steel designation Typical Chemical Composition %
ASTM
UNS number
EN C max Cr Ni Mo N Cu
6 Moly
S31254
1.4547
0.2
19.5-20.5
17.5-18.5
6-6.5
0.18-0.22
0.5 max
Alloy 926
N08926
1.4529
0.2
19-21
24-26
6-7
0.15-0.25
0.5-0.15
Alloy 6XN
N08367
0.2
20-22
24-25.5
6-7
0.20-0.25
0.75 max
904L
904L
N08904
1.4539
0.2
19-23
23-28
4-5
1-2
Alloy 28 *
N08028
1.4563
0.2
26-28
30-34
3-4
0.10 max
0.7-1.50
Duplex S31803 / 32205
1.4462 0.3 21-23 4.5-6.5 2.5-3.5 0.08-0.20
Super Duplex
S32750
1.4410
0.3
24-26
6-8
3-5
0.24-0.32
316L
316L
S31600
1.4401
0.3
16-18
8-12
2-3
304L
304L
S30400
1.4301
0.3
18-20
10-14
* Alloy 28 can also be considered as a Nickel Alloy , however it has been featured in this list for comparison purpose only .
www . heat-exchanger-world . com Heat Exchanger World May 2023
21