Gabriella Olivieri Publications Portfolio Annual Report - 2010 | Page 14
APPEALS
CHIEF Leonard Koerner
DEPUTIES Francis Caputo, Stephen McGrath
The Appeals Division is responsible for nearly all appeals in matters litigated by the Law Department in state and federal
court, and its cases involve virtually every area of substantive law—even including some criminal law issues. Attorneys ?le
approximately 700 appellate briefs annually and appear in approximately 15 percent of the New [????\??\ X[ ??&H
B??]x?&\?Y?\???\?
H?]?[???] ?\? YX\?[? ]??\? H?] H ?]?Z[Y[? LH? H M??\?\?[? ?X?] \?X?\]Y ???Y?[?[?? H?\?{? Y? \??&\??[B?H]?\?[?X?Y]?Y ??XZ?? ?[??[??\?\??[[??[?? H ?[Y] H? H8?'?\?Y?Y? \??&\? ?[x?'x?% ?X? ?]\? ]?\?Y?Y? \??[? ?X?B???X?\???[??? ?YH Z\?[\?Y\??????[[?[]??Y?Y?[??H ?[][?? ? HZY? [?Y ?\???\????X]Y ?] Z\?[\?[Y[? ?[???Y\? ???] K[??? ?[??H ?X?H??X?\?[??\?Y ?[?[??\???X?\?X??Y[? H ?Y??\?YH?\?[? ?[??H?\??Y\?[??\??\?[? ???] K?[??? ?[??H ?X?H??X?\?X??Y[? H ??[?[??\?Y?HH?[????X?\? ?]H\ []H??\? ?
[?? Y[?? H??\??\ X[ ?[??Y\?B?[ ] H ?[H\ YY ??Y?[?[???[?[[?[ ???Y \?\?H]?\?[? ?? ?YH???\??\?\? ?[][?? ? HX?[????[ ??X?]?H ???\???? HYZ[?\? ?][????[ ?[??&\??\??X?\?
P??K??H?\?\?^[Z[?YY?[??\???P??[\?YY\? ??Y \?X?\]Y[?[Y\??[??H?[ ?[[?[Y??? ?XX?X?[? ?\??[Y?HB??[Z[ HY[X?\? ??[Y?Y ]\??\? ?Y? ?Y?Y[? ?[?]Y?H H ?[[?[ ???\?\?Y ?\??[???[Z[?[?\?X?H\??Y\?H]?\?[? ??\ X[ ?[??\?\? ?[][?? ? H8?' ?YK\? ?Z?\??'H ?[H ?Y?\?[????]???\?Y?[X?[?????Y? ?H ?\??\??? H ?Y? ? B?\\?Y[?? ??][? ? ?X\?? H?Y\?? [?H? ??][? ?]?]H ?\??[?? H[[][?] H? ?X?H??X?\?? ??Y ?XZ?B?H ?] \?X??X?\?[? \?[??H ???[??[?[?Y ?\?[? H[??\?Y[? [??Y[??\?[?\??[? ?\??\???&HX???H???] ][?[ ?Y? ?X??\??]?Y[??H?? ?? X???X?[??H \?[????Y?] H[??Y?[]?H?[??]?\?[?] ??^\? ?]?Z[Y[?H???]H \?[????\[?x?&\??[[??H?\? H\\?Y[???Z[[????&H ?Y?\?[ ? ?[?]?] ?X?[??H \?[??B?XZ???[Z[?[[??\?Y?][?[Y?[?? ] H??\[?H ?\??[ ?Y?Z[?? \?[?? ?\?[ ?H]?\?[?[ ?? ??H?[[??H ? H?] x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x?&\??[???[?\???Y?\? ?][?X? ??? ?X?X?H??Y? ?[?X\??\?Y?][??[[??\?]?\?[?] ??^\? ?X??\??[ HY?[?Y H?] H???H?[[??\? ?[][?? ? H ?X?Y\?? H[?X\??? ?\?\??][???[Z\??[?
?K?[?X?[??[Y?H H?]^?[??[Y\??[??H??[Z] YH ? ?\?\??B? ?\?\??][?
?P?
H?[[??Y H??[Z\??[??&\?[?\??[ ???Y \?\? ?Y?\?[????H ??\? H\????Y? ???\????[[?\?[??[????Y\?][???[?X\??\?Y?][??H?\??\\?Y[???]?\??YH??\???\??[?[??]\?Z[?[?? ] H?P?Y??]?H ?[?[?? ? ?YH[? ] \?B??\??? ?] ]?H ?\]Z\?[Y[?[?]\?Z[?[?? ?]\? ????Y\?H ??\? H??\?Y?][??H?] H[ ?? ?]?Z[Y[?[?\ X[?[[??[????&\?\?Y?][?? ???Z[[????[??]?[?YH? H\ \?X\???YH?HH ??\? H??\? ?? ?[?Y ? ?Y]?[? H ?X?H[?Y[ ?XY H[ \?Y H \?X?[??p??YH? H?Z[[???H?Z[[???\?H \??? H ???[ X????8?'Y? X??\? [?[Y[? ??'HY?[? H??[? ?K?[?[?Y ? ?\??H\?[ \??]]?\? ? H\?? ?? H ?[?[]Y [?[Y[? ?? H [YK???L???