thousands of foreigners flocked to Paris . The Internet provides a global dragnet to scoop up cryptocurrency enthusiasts . Coinbase , which offers bitcoin wallets , boasted some 12 million accounts last December — a three-fold increase over the course of the year . While the Mississippi boom minted the first paper “ millionaires ,” bitcoin appeared to be conjuring up digital billionaires — including reportedly the Winklevoss twins of Facebook notoriety .
Speculative Tales
Every great bubble produces great anecdotes . Charles Mackay ’ s famous account of the early bubbles , Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds ( 1841 ), is stuffed with memorable , if rather fanciful , tales . The Dutch tulip mania of the 1630s inspired several legends , including that of the black tulip ( which inspired Alexandre Dumas ’ s eponymous novel ). Mackay narrates a story of a sailor inadvertently eating a priceless tulip bulb after mistaking it for an onion . Even the stories of broken speculators throwing themselves off skyscrapers after the October 1929 crash turn out to be urban legends .
Bitcoin has already produced a number of wonderful yarns . There ’ s the computer programmer who used bitcoin to buy pizzas back in May 2010 . At 2017 , peak prices this snack was estimated to have cost more than $ 150 million . Another story relates how a British IT worker threw away an old computer hard drive which stored a number of bitcoins . A few years later , this digital fortune was valued at more than $ 125 million and the hapless techie was said to be planning to dig up a landfill site to salvage his lost fortune . When the Long Island Iced Tea Corporation , an unprofitable purveyor of soft drinks , changed its name late last year to the Long Blockchain Corporation , its share price soared nearly 300 %.
George Soros argues that a “ super-bubble ” only forms after it has survived a severe test , imbuing speculators with a sense of invincibility . Bitcoin has weathered a number of such trials . After peaking at close to $ 1,000 in late 2013 , it shed more than 75 % of its value over the following 18 months , before starting its more recent , epic ascent . Bitcoin has also survived a number of outright scandals , including grand larceny at the Mt . Gox exchange when billions of dollars ’ worth of bitcoins ( at current value , anyway ) vanished into the ether .
1754 drawing of Scottish-born financier John Law . The bubble created by Law ’ s Mississippi Company is relevant to recent events in the cryptocurrency world .
Easy Money
Great bubbles occur during periods of easy money , when interest rates are low , or falling , and liquidity is super-abundant . The Dutch tulip mania , for instance , appeared in the mid-1630s at a time of large foreign capital inflows into Holland , which spurred money printing by Amsterdam ’ s Wisselbank , Europe ’ s first central bank . Dutch interest rates were also far below their past average levels at the time .
Recent monetary conditions have much in common with the 1630s . At the beginning of 2017 , the world ’ s largest central banks were expanding their balance sheets like never before . At the time of bitcoin ’ s blow-off , some $ 11 trillion worth of bonds worldwide were offering negative yields . The American stock market was more expensive than at any time save for the dotcom peak in early 2000 . This left savers with an uncomfortable dilemma , either speculate or starve .
The ideal speculative object is one which provides no yield and is therefore impossible to value . Think of those tulip bulbs , gold in late 1970s or contemporary art in recent years . Bitcoin , which produces no income , has a restricted new supply and whose ownership is concentrated in
MPI / Stringer
14 FINANCIAL HISTORY | Spring 2018 | www . MoAF . org
thousands of foreigners flocked to Paris.
The Internet provides a global dragnet
to scoop up cryptocurrency enthusiasts.
Coinbase, which offers bitcoin wallets,
boasted some 12 million accounts last
December — a three-fold increase over the
course of the year. While the Mississippi
boom minted the first paper “millionaires,”
bitcoin appeared to be conjuring up digi-
tal billionaires — including reportedly the
Winklevoss twins of Facebook notoriety.
Every great bubble produces great anec-
dotes. Charles Mackay’s famous account
of the early bubbles, Extraordinary Popu-
lar Delusions and the Madness of Crowds
(1841), is stuffed with memorable, if rather
fanciful, tales. The Dutch tulip mania of
the 1630s inspired several legends, includ-
ing that of the black tulip (which inspired
Alexandre Dumas’s eponymous novel).
Mackay narrates a story of a sailor inad-
vertently eating a priceless tulip bulb after
mistaking it for an onion. �ٕ��ѡ���ѽɥ��)����ɽ��������ձ�ѽ�́ѡɽݥ���ѡ���)͕�ٕ́����ͭ�͍Ʌ���́��ѕȁѡ��=�ѽ���(���䁍Ʌ͠���ɸ���ЁѼ�����ɉ���������̸) �э������́��ɕ����ɽ�Ս������յ���)���ݽ���əհ��ɹ̸�Q��ɗ�éѡ�������ѕ�)�ɽ�Ʌ���ȁݡ���͕����э����Ѽ�������)�́��������5��������Ѐ���ܰ�������ɥ���)ѡ�́����݅́��ѥ��ѕ��Ѽ���ٔ����Ё��ɔ)ѡ�������������������ѡ�ȁ�ѽ��ɕ��ѕ�)��܁�� ɥѥ͠�%P�ݽɭ�ȁѡɕ܁�݅䁅�����)�����ѕȁ��ɐ��ɥٔ�ݡ�����ѽɕ�����մ�)��ȁ�����э���̸����܁啅�́��ѕȰ�ѡ�́����х�)����չ��݅́م�Օ���Ё��ɔ�ѡ������ԁ����)���������ѡ��������́ѕ�����݅́ͅ���Ѽ���)���������Ѽ�������������������ͥє�Ѽ�ͅ�م��)��́���Ё����չ���]����ѡ��1����%ͱ����%���)Q���
����Ʌѥ�������չ�ɽ��х�������ٕ��)���ͽ�Ё�ɥ��̰�����������́�������є�����)啅ȁѼ�ѡ��1���� ����������
����Ʌѥ���)��́͡�ɔ��ɥ���ͽ�ɕ�����ɱ������)��ɝ��M�ɽ́�ɝՕ́ѡ�Ё���q����ȵ�Ո�)����t����䁙�ɵ́��ѕȁ�Ё��́���٥ٕ����͕ٕɔ)ѕ�а����ե�������ձ�ѽ�́ݥѠ���͕�͔���)��٥��������丁 �э������́ݕ�ѡ�ɕ�����մ�)��ȁ����Ս���ɥ��̸��ѕȁ���������Ё���͔�Ѽ(�İ���������є����̰��Ё͡�����ɔ�ѡ����Ԕ)�����́م�Ք��ٕȁѡ�������ݥ���������ѡ̰)����ɔ��х�ѥ�����́��ɔ�ɕ���а�������͍��и) �э������́��ͼ����٥ٕ�����յ��ȁ��)���ɥ��Ё͍�����̰�����Ց�����Ʌ�����ɍ���)�Ёѡ��5и�����፡�����ݡ����������́��)������ϊd�ݽ�Ѡ������э���̀��Ё���ɕ�Ёم�Ք�)���݅䤁م��͡�����Ѽ�ѡ���ѡ�ȸ)M���ձ�ѥٔ�Q����(���Ё�Ʌݥ������M���ѥ͠���ɸ���������ȁ)����1�ܸ�Q����Չ�����ɕ�ѕ����1�ߊe�)5��ͥ�ͥ����
�����䁥́ɕ��م�ЁѼ�ɕ���Ё�ٕ��́���ѡ������ѽ���ɕ���ݽɱ��)���5����)ɕ�Ё�Չ���́����ȁ��ɥ�����ɥ��́��)���䁵���䰁ݡ�����ѕɕ�ЁɅѕ́�ɔ���ܰ)�ȁ����������������ե���䁥́����ȵ��ո�)���и�Q����э���ձ������������ȁ���х����)�����ɕ�����ѡ����������́�Ё��ѥ�����)��ɝ����ɕ��������х��������́��Ѽ�!�������)ݡ��������ɕ��������ɥ�ѥ�������ѕȴ)����é]��͕��������ɽ���é����Ё����Ʌ�)�������э����ѕɕ�ЁɅѕ́ݕɔ���ͼ����)����܁ѡ��ȁ���Ё�ٕɅ�����ٕ�́�Ёѡ��ѥ���)I����Ё����х�䁍����ѥ��́��ٔ��Ս�)����������ݥѠ�ѡ������̸�Ёѡ��������)�����������ܰ�ѡ��ݽɱ��é��ɝ��Ё����Ʌ�)����́ݕɔ�����������ѡ��ȁ��������͡����(�ӊ���%99
%0�!%MQ=Ig����M�ɥ��������� ��ܹ5���ɜ)�������ٕȁ����ɔ��Ёѡ��ѥ��������э����e�)���ܵ�����ͽ�����ā�ɥ������ݽ�Ѡ���������)ݽɱ�ݥ���ݕɔ�����ɥ�������ѥٔ�奕��̸)Q�����ɥ�����ѽ�����ɭ�Ё݅́��ɔ)�����ͥٔ�ѡ����Ё���ѥ���ٔͅ���ȁѡ�)��э�������������ɱ�������Q��́���Ёٕͅ��)ݥѠ����չ������х���������������ѡ��)����ձ�є��ȁ�х�ٔ�)Q�������������ձ�ѥٔ������Ё�́����ݡ���)�ɽ٥��́���奕��������́ѡ�ɕ��ɔ�����̴)ͥ����Ѽ�م�Ք��Q��������ѡ�͔��ձ����ձ�̰)����������є�����́�ȁ���ѕ���Ʌ�䁅��)���ɕ���Ё啅�̸� �э�����ݡ�����ɽ�Ս��)�������������́��ɕ��ɥ�ѕ����܁������)����ݡ�͔��ݹ��͡�����
���������Ʌѕ����