Re: Response to“ We’ re Making Kids Soft”
To: Soccer Journal From: Dr. David Carr
Re: Response to“ We’ re Making Kids Soft”
The following is a response from Past President Dr. David Carr to an article in the last Soccer Journal by Brandon Koons, women’ s coach at Otterbein University.
DR. DAVID CARR Lecturer in Coaching Education | Georgia Southern University
his article raises significant questions and concerns, and I take exception to the author’ s
Tpremise that kids of today are soft. One of the concerns is the definition of what is considered“ soft” was not introduced, discussed and settled as an actual condition. It is a broad label that often has a negative connotation but has never been clearly defined as it relates to youth sports and in this case, youth soccer.
I have been fortunate to have had a 50-year career as a soccer coach and coaching educator. I am still teaching. My research is primarily focused on understanding how children can best develop as people and how to create an optimal sport environment for that development.
As we introduce the game to young children, we must promote the following“ soft skills”:
• Receptive and expressive communication
• Developing the ability to physically, mentally and emotionally adapt( resilience),
• Emphasize responsibility
• Ask children to solve problems and make decisions( adaptability)
• Promote leadership – building lifelong character and social skills
• Teach children how to engage with others in the same environment( teamwork)
• Ask them what they think, what they like and what bothers them
These“ soft skills” are crucial for navigating a modern, tech-driven world. Using a holistic athlete-centered approach involves coaching the whole child and this includes all of the“ soft” qualities listed above.
There is a Children’ s Bill of Rights in Sport driven by Project Play which is part of the Aspen Institute. It states that every child has the right to play sports and, when in the care of adults, the human rights they are born with need to be respected. It is designed to create a shared cultural understanding that all youth should have the opportunity to develop as people through sports.
The article,“ We’ re Making Kids Soft,” published in the Spring 2026 Soccer Journal begins with an overview of the negative communication that children are subjected to from coaches, parents, officials and others who are involved in the youth soccer environment. Yelling at children is detrimental to their development. Research indicates that it often leads to increased anxiety, reduced enjoyment and poor performance. It causes increased stress, distractions, and fear of failure and is a major factor in children quitting youth sports. Roughly two-thirds of all children who begin participating in youth sports are no longer playing by the time they become teenagers. It seems the author was trying to say this but then creates a long list of“ must events,” many of which are inappropriate and potentially dangerous.
Youth player safety and well-being should always be the primary concern of all adults who work in youth sports. The game needs to be FUN! Mandating dangerous or adverse conditions seems in opposition to the basic principles of holistic athlete-centered development. The author’ s list of“ must events” to harden children raised additional concerns. Is it the responsibility of youth sports to“ harden” children? What does“ harden” mean? In the article, like“ soft,”“ harden” is not defined. Some of the skills suggested as hard skills are actually soft skills.
Winning is overemphasized and often does not provide a clear picture of how children are learning the game. The process is far more important than the outcome. Practices need to be designed to challenge players to play with an extra player or one less than the other team. Players need to be taught how to play and adapt to what happens in the game. Young players tend to react. As players develop, they learn to anticipate— a huge tactical change in how they play. They often don’ t approach the game as an underdog or the favorite. They want to play and the game is the best teacher.
I am from Vermont and I have played with snow on the field, but we dressed for it. The temperature was
48 | Soccer Journal