An earlier issue of the Soccer Journal published a Q & A piece about my accidental entry into grassroots soccer with newcomer youth, who were supported by Kelowna Community Resources( KCR), in a mid-sized Canadian city where soccer is a thing. I watched the FIFA World Cup to understand why some participants in my grassroots, inclusive soccer program( ISP) engaged in“ chirping” on the field. The volunteer player-coaches from the UBCO Heat men’ s soccer team explained that“ chirping” is part of competitive soccer culture. I observed and learned that chirping can be“ fun,” but it could also escalate into negative name-calling, comments putting down someone’ s competence or taunting gestures. I saw these identical behaviors and next-level harassment manifest at the FIFA World Cup.
Since Michael Kodama, the Coaches Communities Relations Manager at United Soccer Coaches, also served as the FIFA Safeguarding and Anti-discrimination Venue Manager at the Kansas City site, I consulted him to better understand these cultural practices and what they mean for young people in the ISP. I often shared my reactions with Michael, wondering how youth engaged with their identities and what they learned from adult role models on the pitch.
The impact of chirping varies significantly by age and development. Acceptable“ chirping” focuses on specific comments regarding execution of skills on the field. Conversely, hurtful“ chirping” is intended to criticize, attack, stigmatize and discriminate against protected human rights like race, skin tone, gender, assumed sexual identity and religion.
Players who are young adults can handle negative chirping better than younger people with limited life experiences. The impact is far greater on youth managing resettlement in an unfamiliar environment with limited social connections. This targeted harm can expand into group bullying, hazing and online hate, leaving victims with nowhere to escape— as seen with the toxic online abuse directed at World Cup players and referees immediately post-match.
FIFA utilizes a safeguarding policy and an anti-racism protocol to deter discrimination at the professional level. To maximize protection, safeguarding must be enforceable and operate in alignment with local cultures to confront issues like the homophobic chant heard in Mexico or anti-Black messages in the stands and on social media. However, because the current safeguarding policy for children does not address the individual psychological impacts of exposure to hostility, coaches and parents must step in to fill the gap. Coaches are best positioned to do this by showcasing how inclusive soccer is a significant part of the beautiful game.
I was also fascinated by the contrasting emotional displays across matches. It was deeply moving to see players from opposing teams cross over to hug, touch foreheads, and physically comfort each other through loss and grief. They operated on unwritten rules of friendship, respect and relationality— the epitome of good sportsmanship. For me, seeing the emotional life of soccer is one of the most important legacies of the 2026 FIFA World Cup, offering a profound example of global inclusion during ongoing humanitarian crises. This legacy centers on emotional responsiveness and bearing witness to practices of inclusion / exclusion on the field, in the stands and in fan zones.
This brings me back to my ISP, which serves as a space for diverse youths from ages 6 to 17 to play soccer with the support of the university varsity players. The unspoken purpose was to provide support to youths resettling in Canada from global conflict zones. Adults often assume young people adapt quickly, but they require structured support tailored to their human development needs. The ISP allowed them to restore social connections and meet a diverse peer group they likely wouldn’ t have encountered in their countries of origin.
Over two years, the participants and volunteer playercoaches developed deep empathy and a sense of collective responsibility. A critical component of this was the specialized two-day training the varsity players received, covering FIFA’ s Anti-Racism Protocol, accessibility and neurodiversity. The Head Coach, Dante Zanatta, the lead Assistant Coach, Tom Flanagan, and I worked collaboratively toward this common purpose.
I targeted chirping as a no-go zone because these youth participants had survived organized discrimination, war, genocide and political persecution. The ISP was designed to
26 | Soccer Journal