Unite has helped a few members in the past to resolve checktest issues by obtaining a copy of the written report, which often also contains notes written by the examiner during the test.
Being able to read the detail in these reports has helped both the ADI and their rep/trainer to identify and clarify queries some weeks after the test.
In a response to concerns, the ADI registrar admits that the SC1 needs to be used in conjunction with the verbal debrief for the ADI to have any understanding of their errors. He states that the debrief remains a key aspect of the assessment. So unless the ADI has a very good memory, and more importantly has understood the debrief, they will have no detailed record of their mistakes for later reflection.
And in the case of any dispute, the ADI has absolutely no evidence, other than a number, to be able to make any complaint. Any cynic would say that’s exactly why no records are being kept. An ADI has very little grounds for appeal against a checktest. From next April, the ADI and their trainer will have no rights to question any assessment whatsoever.
Despite being asked on several occasions, DSA has to date failed to explain why no detailed report is being made as is current procedure, or why any notes the examiner makes during the test must be destroyed immediately after the test.
The DSA doesn't want to keep records of tests conducted, and doesn't want you recording it either.
The only way an ADI will in future have any protection from an unjustified or wrong decision, which is happening all the time, is to video and audio record their own standards check. Providing the camera is unable to capture the examiner’s image, there is no data protection issues, and the video and audio recording will provide an accurate capture of everything that happened during the test.
The ADI should also be allowed to audio record the debrief. Only someone who is frightened of having their mistakes or incompetence recorded can object to that.
DSA says it isn’t their policy to allow recording of tests. ADI’s are not employed by DSA and therefore have no interest in what its policies are. Unlike murderers who have several appeal channels, the ADI has none, and should therefore protect their livelihood.
Dave Thomas - Founder member of the only union for ADI’s