Columbus Freepress - November 7th 2013 Nov 7 2013 | Page 7
Ain’t no love in the heart
that the US was/is the morally superior party in
the wars it’s been fighting for the past ten years
probably numbers in the thousands. There is no
Islamist celebrated figure among the radical left
a la Ho Chi Minh. The most ardent criticism
still comes from a fundamentally liberal
Suppose that the reported explosion was an actual standpoint, of a desire to see American force
attack. Explosions and bomb attacks happen
used for good. Nobody argues that American
in Iraq on a regular basis, and yet now that the
imperialism actually deserves to be fought,
country is no longer under occupation, they don’t much less that political Islam is a valid way to
constitute “news” to American media. Back in the do so. We may have avoided military aggression
real world, the operative question is, why would
in Syria, but Assad is a secular dictator, and
the nation’s largest media outlets report on a story
indeed much of the skepticism was over how
using anonymous sources that wasn’t even close
the plan fit in with the goals of the War on
to being fully developed? Because the US foreign
Terror. Currently, all signs point to Congress
policy apparatus (insert-historical-imperial-power
scuttling any deal President Obama might be
here) gets to set the terms of the discourse for
able to reach with Iran.
everyone from war-machine sycophants to postBack in August, when the same embassy
colonial theorists.
closed in Yemen, along with other US embassies
This is the dilemma that those seeking to resist
hegemony or create a just world face. One of the around the Middle East, Al Jazeera had a
token imperial stooge, on Inside Story, who
most effective ways to make the powers that be
irrelevant is to treat them as such, but in doing so said the closings were in a response to “some
you allow the hegemonist propaganda to continue very specific intelligence, particularly within
the region. It may not have been specific”
unmolested. Applied to the non-explosion, if
and of course that the intelligence came from
you’re a purported anti-imperialist media outlet,
do you ignore the story or do you report it with a intercepted communications. These closings
healthy context critical of US drone strikes in the came at a time when hubbub around the
Snowden leaks/NSA surveillance story was at
area?
a high point. All of which is to say that master
This dilemma is more than theoretical. The
propagandists these guys are not. And yet
more insidious effects of the media lie not in the
they’ve largely managed to succeed, not least
stories people read, but the ones they skim, the
because whenever they clear their throat, we all
ticker feed, or the ones they don’t even click on.
It is in the milieu where the US war machine has come running.
achieved its most complete propaganda victory.
The number of Americans who do not believe
Address all hate mail to [email protected]
All Quiet on the Western Front
By Peter M. Gunn
“NOW MORE THAN EVER”
On Monday, October 28, an explosion and heavy
gunfire were reported outside the US embassy
in Yemen. You may have heard about it. It got
a brief mention on all the cable news channels
with promises of more on this story as it develops
including possible casualties. It pierced my
leftist information silo through a small paragraph
on Gawker mentioning this fact and nothing
else. It was, a sobering reminder, indeed, of the
dangerous world we live in. A moment of pause,
for reflection that for all the criticism we do and
outrage we share about the military-industrial
complex, they really are working to keep us,
Americans, safe. A few hours later, there was
more on this story as it developed: the explosions
were fireworks from a wedding party.
Now this is far from the first time that the
US has “mistaken” a wedding party for socalled terrorist activity, as quite a few former
citizens of Afghanistan can attest to. Nor is this
far from the first time that questionable news
reports have been deployed in an effort to keep
the populace good and scared. I will admit that
were it not for this column, I would have never
bothered to follow up on the story. No news
outlet. ever reports the boner-killing truth-filled
updates as breathlessly as it does the the initial
scandalizing lies. This is of course not a bug of
the news media, but a feature, and as much as I
love Chomsky, it’s not just about manufacturing
consent, but about the nature of the concept of
news itself.
When we talk about the evils of imperialism,
much is made about the damage it does militarily,
economically and politically, but more than that it
shapes and limits our fundamental understanding
of the world itself. Regions, cultures, borders
become defined solely for the purposes of
imperial interests. There is no concept of “the
West” without an Oriental East to colonize and
conquer, and any and all discourse about the West
plays off that tradition. Similarly, Afghanistan and
Iraq are not in the same region, historically and
environmentally. They are completely different
cultures with different languages and traditions.
However, in order for its War On Terror/Project
for a New American Century agenda to make
sense, the Bush administration started to push
a new regional formulation called the “Greater
Middle East.” 9 years later, and the war in
Afghanistan is colloquially understood as a war in
the Middle East, with all of the wonderful Clashof-Civilizations elements implied.
And once those regions have been defined,
our understanding of what goes on in them is
also almost entirely shaped by imperial interests.
7