INCORPORATING COLD CHAIN
COLD LINK AFRICA PUBLISHED BY Interact Media Defined ( Pty ) Ltd 13A Riley Rd , Bedfordview 2009 , South Africa PO Box 695 , Edenvale , 1610 Tel : + 27 ( 0 ) 11 579 4940 Web : www . interactmedia . co . za
PUBLISHING UNIT LEAD : Dale Macnamara sales @ interactmedia . co . za
EDITOR : Benjamin Brits benjamin @ interactmedia . co . za
CONSULTING EDITOR : John Ackermann
Banking on climate change : The rise of climate finance related disputes
By Kirsten Wolmarans , partner & Brittany Leroni , associate at Webber Wentzel
ADVERTISING SALES External sales : Dale Macnamara sales @ interactmedia . co . za Zeldalee du Toit | zeldalee @ interactmedia . co . za
SUBSCRIPTIONS : Maxlee Marange | mmarange @ interactmedia . co . za Ralph Shongwe | ralph @ interactmedia . co . za
SUB-EDITOR : David Smith david @ interactmedia . co . za
DESIGN AND LAYOUT : Glyniss Bone glyniss @ interactmedia . co . za
PROCESS CO-ORDINATOR : Lebo Bucibo lebo @ interactmedia . co . za
MANAGEMENT Finance / operations : Sean Macnamara sean @ interactmedia . co . za Finance : Laetitia Arnott | laetitia @ interactmedia . co . za
PRINTING : TYPO
DISTRIBUTION : distribution @ interactmedia . co . za
CIRCULATION : Apr - Jun 2022 Print : 2012 | Online : 2045 | Total : 4057
ENVIRONMENT-FRIENDLY PRINTING : All paper is sourced from the Forest Stewardship Council and Chain of Custody-certified suppliers . All wastepaper from the plant is recycled . All used plates are recycled . All new printing equipment is purchased for low energy-consumption levels and low volatile organic-compound emissions .
DISCLAIMER : While every reasonable precaution has been taken to ensure the accuracy of the advice and information given , neither the editor , publisher , proprietor , staff , nor any official body represented or published in this issue , will accept responsibility for any damages , loss , injuries , or false claims that may arise or be made in the content . Including but not limited to any references to gender , religion , politics , ethnicity , or personal preferences of any editorial contribution whether an industry expert , advertiser through sponsored or paid content or contract writer . We subscribe to the Code of Conduct of the Advertising Regulatory Board ( info @ arb . co . za ) and the Press Ombudsman ( see below ). Disclaimers by individual companies are hereby overridden by this disclaimer .
COPYRIGHT : Reproduction of any of the content and photographs is expressly forbidden in terms of the Copyright Act of 1987 with all amendments . All requests to reproduce must be made in writing to the publisher and such confirmation must be given in writing before proceeding . A copy of where the reproduction was published must be supplied to the publisher at the above address . All publication and exhibition titles are registered as trademarks in terms of the Trademarks Act of 1993 and are held by Interact Media Defined ( Pty ) Ltd , Reg No 2014 / 092774 / 07 .
PRESS OMBUDSMAN : This publication has committed itself to maintain the highest standards of journalism as embodied in the Press Code of Professional Practice . If you believe we have failed to report news and comment accurately , honestly and fairly , you may lodge a complaint with the Press Ombudsman either by email , letter , or by telephoning the office for the procedure to be followed . Tel : + 27 ( 0 ) 11 484 3612 / 8 . Email : enquiries @ ombudsman . org . za Website : www . presscouncil . org . za for the press code and / or the complaints form .
Following environmental , social and governance ( ESG ) trends , South Africa ’ s banking sector is gearing up to provide sustainable financing .
This shift into a new era of clean energy will give rise to complex ESG related disputes , and stakeholders should consider including an arbitration clause in underlying contracts to mitigate their risks .
South Africa ' s economy and energy system is one of the most coal-dependent in the world . South Africa ' s ratification of the Paris Agreement has , however , set in motion a rapid energy transformation , with the goal of decarbonising the South African economy by 2050 . In the energy sector , South Africa estimates that the process of shifting to low-carbon technologies and the implementation of adaptation requirements to reduce greenhouse emissions will require roughly USD300-billion .
Sustainability-linked financing offers a significant opportunity for banks . Corporate clients , also looking to comply with ESG objectives , would rather partner with banks that have implemented ESG initiatives in their own processes and systems .
South Africa ' s top banks are opting to use the United Nations ' Sustainable Development Goals as a guide to inform their approach to business and are setting targets to link to the Paris Agreement , the local regulatory framework , the South African Financial Sector Code , and the King Code on Corporate Governance for South Africa .
However , doing the right thing , and becoming green , is not easy . In the absence of clear direction and regulation on how to best operate to achieve these goals , disputes will become increasingly common . This is especially the case where there is a gap between voluntary company commitments and practice . History has shown that this creates fertile ground for disputes .
Tracking global patterns , ESG-related disputes are arising in the context of multiple fields of law , across jurisdictions , and involving issues such as investment in renewable energy initiatives , asset divestment , breaches of representations or warranties relating to climate-change commitments , or where the receiving country is unable to meet environmental covenants which may be put in place under agreements . These disputes will be complex , and often the subject matter will constitute
Jukka Niittymaa | Pixabay
Doing the right thing , and becoming green , is not easy .
largely unexplored terrain . The South African banking sector will not be immune .
While the spotlight is on ESG , the reputational fall-out and financial repercussions of ESG-related disputes are likely to be significant for the party on the receiving end . Despite this reality , a risk that is often overlooked by parties to a contract is the dispute resolution mechanism . When the implementation of contracts goes awry , disputes arise , and how such disputes are resolved gives rise to a new set of risks .
An important risk mitigation factor that all banks should insist upon when entering into contracts is an agreement to arbitrate . By resorting to arbitration to resolve disputes , not only will the parties benefit from confidentiality , and the inherent flexibility to choose arbitrators with adequate knowledge of the relevant issues , but they will also be able to tailor the procedure to accommodate the dispute . This is especially the case when banks are implicated in disputes with an ' international ' element , such as a dispute between banks ( as investors ) and hoststates ; or where the parties have their places of business in different states ; or where the subject matter of the dispute is outside the state where the parties have their places of business . In these instances , the banks will be best equipped to resolve their disputes through international arbitration . Not only does this forum offer a neutral playing field in which to resolve the dispute , but the result is global recognition and enforcement of awards through the New York Convention .
To illustrate the advantages of electing arbitration , a local population may be directly impacted by an investment in a new gas pipeline to be constructed through a forest , impacting natural resources for the residents in the area . Entering a submission to arbitrate agreement will avoid court proceedings involving numerous parties , spanning several jurisdictions , with the potential of conflicting court orders . Instead , the arbitration proceedings will provide certainty , finality , and an enforceable award across states .
In summary , the legal and commercial pressures on banks and their corporate clients in moving towards a net zero target by 2050 will create additional risks and challenges . Not only will contractual relationships need to be overhauled , but so will internal practices and policies . To mitigate the risks of when a dispute arises stemming from ESG obligations , serious consideration should always be given to including an arbitration clause in the underlying contract . CLA
Doing the right thing , and becoming green , is not easy . In the absence of clear direction and regulation on how to best operate to achieve these goals , disputes will become increasingly common .
PROTECTION OF PERSONAL INFORMATION ( POPI ) ACT : You are receiving this medium in accordance with the POPI Act as a registered reader , where you have accepted receipt of the publication and / or other related information as defined in the Act . In the event that Interact Media Defined ( IMD ) and / or IMD Conferences Exhibitions and Workshops has received your details from a third party ( i . e ., association , official bodies etc .) we have the assurance that they have your permission to provide your information to us or as a result of being a member . You have granted permission to store such information as required by the Act . We assure readers / users that the information provided is used expressly for the intended purpose of dissemination of information by the companies print and / or electronic means and / or exhibitions relevant to your industry and is not shared beyond the scope of these businesses . If you have reason to believe that IMD and / or IMD Conferences Exhibitions and Workshops is in breach of the POPI Act and as it relates to your personal information , please escalate to privacy @ interactmedia . co . za . Should you not be satisfied with our company ’ s response to the handling of your personal information , you can contact the Information Commissioner : complaints . IR @ justice . gov . za . For general enquiries , contact inforeg @ justice . gov . za
COLD LINK AFRICA • January / February 2023 www . coldlinkafrica . co . za 5