China Policy Journal Volume 1, Number 1, Fall 2018 | Page 81

China Policy Journal
Table 5. The Details of the Bilateral Transfer Between Cities
Based on model “hypothesis 2” Cities k
City j �WTP =
WW jj (QQ kk − IIII), k:
direct upstream
neighbor
Water
quality
Population
(million)
Distance
to
upstream
neighbor
(km)
Total
transfer
received
PES transfer matrix WW jj,kk (positive values means transfer from city k (upstream) to city j (downstream),
negative values means transfer from city j (downstream) to city k (upstream)on the line to city in the
column)
Qujing Guigang Wuzhou Yunfu Zhaoqing Foshan Zhongshan Guangzhou Zhuhai
Qujing — IV 6.4 — — — — — — — — — —
Guigang −10.15 II 3.8 268 38.57 38.57 — — — — — — — —
Wuzhou 0 III 2.9 261 0 29.44 −29.44 — — — — — — —
Yunfu −5.57 III 2.4 100.2 13.37 24.36 −24.36 13.37 — — — — — —
Zhaoqing −5.57 II 3.9 67.9 21.72 39.59 −39.59 21.72 0 — — — — —
Foshan 0 IV 7.2 81.12 0 73.08 −73.08 40.10 0 −40.10 — — — —
Zhongshan −10.15 II 3.1 133 31.47 31.47 −31.47 17.27 0 −17.27 31.47 — — —
Guangzhou 0 IV 12.7 31.69 0 128.91 −128.91 70.74 0 −70.74 128.91 −128.91 — —
Zhuhai −10.15 IV 1.6 38.6 16.24 16.24 −16.24 8.92 0 −8.92 16.24 −16.24 16.24 —
Total payment due to the responsibility of transboundary pollution of city k 381.66 −343.09 172.12 0 −137.03 176.62 −145.15 16.24 —
Based on model “hypothesis 3” Cities k
City j �WTP =
WW jj ( QQ kk−IIII
),
1+ln (DD jj,kk )
k: direct
upstream
neighbor
Water
quality
Population
(million)
Distance
to
upstream
neighbor
(km)
Total
transfer
received
PES transfer matrix WW jj,kk (positive values means transfer from city k (upstream) to city j (downstream),
negative values means transfer from city j (downstream) to city k (upstream)on the line to city in the
column)
Qujing Guigang Wuzhou Yunfu Zhaoqing Foshan Zhongshan Guangzhou Zhuhai
Qujing — IV 6.4 — — — — — — — — — — —
Guigang −7.37 II 3.8 268 28.01 28.01 — — — — — — — —
Wuzhou 0 III 2.9 261 0 12.51 −12.51 — — — — — — —
Yunfu −6.78 III 2.4 100.2 16.27 8.93 −8.93 16.27 — — — — — —
Zhaoqing −8.08 II 3.9 67.9 31.52 13.27 −13.27 19.73 11.79 — — — — —
Foshan 0 IV 7.2 81.12 0 22.24 −22.24 27.96 11.02 −38.98 — — — —
Zhongshan −11.64 II 3.1 133 36.09 8.31 −8.31 8.72 2.05 −10.77 36.09 — — —
Guangzhou 0 IV 12.7 31.69 0 33.04 −33.04 33.52 8.12 −41.64 153.33 −153.33 — —
Zhuhai −19.57 IV 1.6 38.6 31.32 4.01 −4.01 3.92 0.86 −4.78 14.33 −14.33 31.32 —
Total payment due to the responsibility of transboundary pollution of city k 130.32 −102.31 110.12 33.84 −96.17 203.75 −167.66 31.32 —
78