From the Editor
http://www.businesstoday.in
Hope vs Expectation
I
n the first two Budgets he presented after the NDA government led by Prime
Minister Narendra Modi came to power, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley trod a
cautious and conservative path. In the first one, he did not have many options
perhaps – the government had been formed in the middle of the financial year, and
the Budget had to be presented within a fairly short period of his taking charge. He
largely stuck to the line of thinking that had been outlined in the Vote on Account
earlier in the year by his predecessor P. Chidambaram of the UPA government.
However, when he rose to make his second Budget speech on February 28,
2015, there were many expectations that the finance minister would present some
truly pathbreaking proposals or unleash a lot of new initiatives to boost the
economy. The time seemed right to do so. The finance minister had been on the
saddle for nine months and had sufficient time to study and understand the problems in the economy. The Central government was still in its honeymoon period,
and there were enough tailwinds in the Indian economy. Crude oil prices kept
sliding, giving the government more ammunition to its import bill, narrow the
trade deficit, and generally raise some additional revenues. The slump in crude
and other commodity prices was also helping inflation come down.
Unfortunately, the second Budget also remained much on the beaten path. While
most businessmen and some economists praised it in public, many of them in private
conversations admitted that Jaitley had squandered a golden opportunity to do more
about subsidies, spur growth or help improve social indicators such as education
and health. Still no one had any serious problems with the
Budget. In fact, the basic economic ideas of its predecessor,
the UPA government, were considered sound, in general.
The problem with the UPA government that had been
voted out, as many business and financial leaders agreed,
was not in its ideas but in its implementation and in the
corruption allegations that plagued it. So, for a government to continue with those ideas while improving on the
implementation would do much for economic growth,
was the general consensus. And the feeling was that the
prime minister was a master of implementation and he
would straighten the kinks in the system.
As he prepares his third Budget, Jaitley has to contend with more problems
perhaps than he would want. Despite India’s September quarter GDP growth rate
being clocked as 7.4 per cent, many of the leading macroeconomic numbers – from
exports to capital spending by corporates – is down. Revenues in a host of industries are down, though profits have been maintained through cost-cutting. But
cost-cutting is never an ideal option because it invariably involves reduction in
employment, and that in turn reduces consumer spending.
There are other problems as well in the overseas markets, and the finance minister cannot depend on a booming global economy coming to the rescue of the domestic economy anytime – at least not for a couple of years.
There is also a sense in the corporate world that the government has not been
as successful in implementation of many programmes on the ground as it should
have been. And in Parliament, it has hit a logjam despite enjoying brute majority
in the Lower House. Indeed, some of the most crucial economic bills it has introduced have been successfully stalled by the Opposition.
Will this be another conventional Budget or a bold one where radical ideas are
introduced? Most people expect the former but hope for the latter. Many finance
ministers perform best when they face a challenging external situation. Everyone
is hoping that Finance Minister Jaitley is one of that breed, though expectations
in general are muted.
[email protected]
@ProsaicView
Editor-in-Chief: Aroon Purie
Group Chief Executive Officer: Ashish Bagga
Group Editorial Director: Raj Chengappa
I
Editor: Prosenjit Datta
Managing Editor: Rajeev Dubey
Deputy Editors: Alokesh Bhattacharyya, Venkatesha Babu,
Anand Adhikari
I
CORRESPONDENTS
Senior Editors: P.B. Jayakumar, Nevin John, Goutam Das
Senior Associate Editors: Mahesh Nayak, Ajita Shashidhar,
Joe C. Mathew
Associate Editors: E. Kumar Sharma, Dipak Mondal,
Manu Kaushik, Anilesh Mahajan
Senior Assistant Editors: Sarika Malhotra,
Chanchal Pal Chauhan, Sumant Banerji
Assistant Editor: Nidhi Singal
I
RESEARCH
Principal Research Analyst: Niti Kiran
I
COPY DESK
Senior Editors: Rishi Joshi, Mahesh Jagota
Associate Editor: Samarpan Dutta
Chief Copy Editors: Gadadhar Padhy, Sapna Nair Purohit
Senior Sub Editor: Devika Singh
I
PHOTOGRAPHY
Photo Editor: Vivan Mehra
Deputy Chief Photographer: Shekhar Ghosh
Principal Photographer: Rachit Goswami
Senior Photographer: Nilotpal